re: What is your top 10 QB list?

I refuse to rank the top tier of QBs. They are all very close. Rodgers probably had the best 2011, but Brees was marginally better in the second half of the season. Brady is not too shabby either. Peyton is a question mark, but I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

1. Rodgers
1. Brees
1. Brady
1. Peyton

5. Romo
6. Roethlisberger
7. Eli
8. Rivers (he was five before his terrible season, but I think his track record and being coached by Norv Turner gives Phil some leeway)

9. Ryan
10. Stafford (with one more tier 2 season under his belt, I will move him up)
11. Schaub
12. Cutler
13. Vick
14. Newton

In all honesty, the difference between my three tiers is very negligable and can be swapped. For example, I could swap Rivers and Romo or Cutler and Ryan and really have no opposition to it.