Started By
Message

re: *OFFICIAL* Fringe M/TV Board rewatch thread (current episodes discussion p. 60)

Posted on 2/16/15 at 11:16 am to
Posted by jamsmiley
Zachary La
Member since Nov 2008
632 posts
Posted on 2/16/15 at 11:16 am to
quote:

How old are you? Just wondering if you're maybe younger and that explains your now knowing of MP.



I'll be 25 on the 1st

heard of MP just never seen it.

I only watched one episode so far. I'll watch the other today. I may post tomorrow

Posted by catholictigerfan
Member since Oct 2009
56009 posts
Posted on 2/18/15 at 8:15 am to
did you guys watch episode 11 yet?

if you have I'll start with some comments.

When Olivia was struggling to keep on one side, it seemed like the observers were very slow to respond. Maybe that was just me.

All of a sudden normal guns can kill observers? Or do they have special in the alternate universe?

Did it take that long for the observers to figure out there was an alternate universe or did they just never bother to invade the other side?

I know I didn't do my typical responses but decent episode. I like how they brought back the alternates it has been a while.

Looking forward to the season finale.
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/18/15 at 8:19 am to
Haven't done my homework for this week. Might start on it tonight.
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/18/15 at 8:36 am to
Still waiting for discussion from last week's episodes (and the week before I believe)...

This week:

The Boy Must Live

Ah, the good ole water tank. I remember the days of "using the tank is a bad idea, and getting in it multiple times is a REALLY dangers and bad idea."



So wait, the Observers can jump that easily around time and into the past/future? Then all of this shouldn't matter...but I guess, as we've talked about, that's one of the main problems when time travel is introduced.

Walter has these memories of the past, like when Peter came to visit him, and Peter tells him "How can he [September] make you see a life you didn't live?" What the frick? Walter didn't live those things? Of course he did...we saw that he did over four seasons so far. Peter resetting in the machine shouldn't have erased those things because Peter is still here. I have a feeling this won't ever be explained and it's a huge gripe I have. Can anybody explain that shite to me?



Is September/Donald proof that the tech being embedded into your spine isn't actually as life-threatening (or damaging to your humanity) like they explained to Peter (to make him take his out)?

Michael is September's son...that's right; I do remember that happening.

That bomb thing in September's apartment sure as hell took long enough to detonate. What a waste...that was WAAAAAAAAA too slow.



White tulip. Awwww shite.



Good job, Mike. Way to go and get captured on purpose...you're only the most important part of this whole goddamn plan. You had ONE job..







Liberty

IIRC, doesn't Michael boss up on Windmark and make his nose bleed? Yup...thought I remembered that.

So he's being held in a detention center on Liberty Island? Well that should be NBD for Olivia since she's broken out of that place in one way or another about 37 times now..

Peter to Liv: "What if I lose you too?" Correct me if I'm wrong, but if this whole thing works and they get Etta back, wouldn't that mean he'd get Liv back too? So even if she dies on this mission getting Michael, if the plan works, it all resets and they are together again.

Walter putting that doctor in his place on the cortexiphan was boom-worthy awesome.



And Liv is moving and jerking around an awful lot for having a needle stuck directly into her brain stem.

Peter calling Walter "dad" again. Awww damn.



I'm curious as to why the Observers wouldn't have invaded the altverse when they invaded this one. Clearly the altverse were in cahoots with this one during last season, and the people are pretty much the same (hell, the Lincoln in the altverse is literally the same Lincoln from this one since he chose to stay over there). Seems like an awfully bad decision to ignore taht universe when it could be such an asset to be used to get around things and defeat the Observers. And on that note, why haven't they used that more often? Maybe because it's so hard to cross over?

Faulivia!!!



I still want both Livs to make out with each other.



Fauxlivia and Link haven't aged a bit. It's like they didn't even try to make them look older, despite it being like 21 years later.

How did that Observer follow Liv to the altverse so easily? If the Obs can see someone disappear and automatically know where they went and be able to follow them, then their time jumping skills present even more of a problem than I originally thought. That was instantaneous and he followed her to the altverse in a heartbeat...and then another one (who wasn't even there) did the same thing. Why have they even been searching at all for these people when they can simply morph straight to where they are, no matter what universe they're in..?

Also, how did Link and Fauxliv shoot the Obs with normal guns? The first guy wasn't looking, so okay, but the second one that crossed over was looking right at them. I thought Obs could dodge/grab bullets or whatever, which is why the resistance uses those special guns that shoot extra fast.

Why is Windmark questioning this loyalist at all? Can't he just read his mind and get the answers? Maybe he was testing his loyalty and seeing if he would try to lie..?
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/18/15 at 8:39 am to
quote:

catholictigerfan

I had pretty much the same issues that you had with the episode.

Solid episodes though.
Posted by jamsmiley
Zachary La
Member since Nov 2008
632 posts
Posted on 2/18/15 at 10:15 am to
The Boy Must Live


I would like to know more about how they manage to create the observers with machines using DNA from other people


This is one of my issues with seasons five. The observers could have taken over any time period they want. They could have went back in time and killed Walters father’s father’s father. Or least go to a time where the people would put up less of a fight

for logical people it seems weird to put faith in a probability

Windmark narrowly escaping is the equivalent of movies where the action here escapes the bomb by running, without any regard to the heat blowing off half is back


If peter wasn't the important boy why, did Peter's son Henry have to be erased?
Liberty

And the award for best mute in a drama goes to?
Anomaly XB-6783746

For his ability to look sad and useless at the same time. Making absolutely no attempt to save his own life. Outstanding work young man.

I’ve been patiently waiting for the reintroduction of Cortexiphan as guess they waited to save it for the right time

Walters mind has been fixed but he Is still called Astrid Asgard


I don’t remember seeing August
Posted by jamsmiley
Zachary La
Member since Nov 2008
632 posts
Posted on 2/19/15 at 9:35 am to
quote:

Also, how did Link and Fauxliv shoot the Obs with normal guns?


Those are the same type of guns that the redhead used in season 4 when she shot September. William Bell created them

quote:

I'm curious as to why the Observers wouldn't have invaded the altverse when they invaded this one.


Maybe the the other universes are too advanced in technology for the observers. I always had an issues with plot issue
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/20/15 at 7:17 pm to

Wow. Down to the last 3 episodes. It will be interesting to see if I have mellowed on the Finale. I hated it on the first watch. Everyone talked about how great it was and a perfect ending to the show and I thought it was hot garbage with more flaws than the rest of the show combined.

Season 5X11
The Boy Must Live


How long have they been back? Once again, the observers sure aren't very observant since Pete and The Gang have been using power, lights and I would assume the bathroom in the old Harvard office for months. I find it somewhat odd, since they tripped an alarm the first time they were there, yet nobody has noticed the alarm was disabled. Nobody has noticed a power spike. Nobody has heard flushing toilets.

Just isn't the same with Walter in the tank.



Too bad Olivia's top wasn't too restrictive.

Once again, I am not a big fan of shows that show dream states to be so damn clear and coherent.


As we have said too many times this season, if they can hop from time to time so easily, it makes no sense that they could ever be stopped.

Good Walter / Bad Walter....blah blah blah.

All of the observers and the loyalists are looking for the gang so the smart thing to do is hang out on the street and chat for half an hour about memories and feelings.



Here we go. Part of the reason I don't like the finale. Michael may have emotion and superior intellect but Michael was achieved THROUGH The Observers being born and refined. I don't see how you could just jump straight to Michael.

The jack wagons in 2167 will see Michael as the PROOF that their project WORKS not that it doesn't work. Just my two cents and honestly nobody can convince me otherwise.

Shouldn't the GodKid be able to travel through time on his own with an Observer device? Ought to be a piece of cake even without the device since he is supposedly so much more advanced than the Observers.

Nothing like a booby trap that FLASHES RED to warn trespassers of their impending death. That was just plain weak.

They sure love them some monorail but do we ever see it?

I know Windmark is showing signs of emotion which might be making him somewhat irrational, but I still don't buy for a second that he wouldn't immediately snap Michael's neck.


Season 5X12
Liberty


Hey! Great to see Liberty Island again. Wonder if it is still easy to break into. Must be even easier now that it is only used as the #1 detention center in Observer Paradise.


If he hadn't already killed him, here is where Windmark really would have snapped Michael's neck.

Windmark running out like a scared little biotch. :lol:

They already knew the kid was an anomaly. He was already scheduled for termination. The whole testing Michael is stupid. Lets find out things we already knew when we stopped his maturation process and scheduled him for termination.


Yay! Fauxlivia!


Oh dear!

Cokes, would you care to explain to me how anyone in the Walternate universe has any idea who Olivia is? Man, they really shite the bed with the whole Peter erasing himself from the universe plot. Ok, MAYBE and that is a real big maybe Olivia because of her treatment she was somehow able to MELD with both universes but they didn't even attempt to explain how anyone else can remember anything about the Peterverse.

Now we are just supposed to believe that everyone in the Fauxverse can remember Olivia? About 30 million plot problems... too many.... error...error.....


Error.....error....error...

Man....even 20 years later and Lincoln is still a bit creepy with Olive.

Great. So not only can they beebop from time to time, they can also beebop from universe to universe with zero difficulty.

I'm telling you, Windmark really blows at his job.

Windmark has all these super powers and yet he is as effective as Frank Burns.

The first observer watched Olivia phase out so maybe I get that he could hop. How did the second observer hop universes? If they are constantly connected or they can track each other then the captured Observers were bullshite in past episodes.

Well, after those two, I have a feeling that I have not mellowed at all on the FINALE!




This post was edited on 2/20/15 at 7:20 pm
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/20/15 at 7:40 pm to
quote:

I remember the days of "using the tank is a bad idea

Silly rabbit! LSD Isolation Trips are for kids!

quote:

Then all of this shouldn't matter...but I guess, as we've talked about, that's one of the main problems when time travel is introduced.




quote:

I have a feeling this won't ever be explained and it's a huge gripe I have. Can anybody explain that shite to me?


Yes. Bad writing. What's next?

quote:

proof that the tech being embedded into your spine isn't actually as life-threatening (or damaging to your humanity)

They didn't just remove the tech. Donald said they experimented on him. Called it reversion therapy, so they devolved him.

quote:

Good job, Mike. Way to go and get captured on purpose.

He ran the numbers. Remember he is smarter than anyone. I assume he ran the scenarios and the only way for all of them to escape was for him to be captured.

Not sure why the loyalists and observers just gave up searching. Clearly the Gang was near if the kid was there. CONTRIVANCE.

quote:

Well that should be NBD for Olivia since she's broken out of that place in one way or another about 37 times now..


Great minds! We think alike.

quote:

I'm curious as to why the Observers wouldn't have invaded the altverse when they invaded this on


Their universe was damaged so perhaps it was too hard to run the numbers over there. Also, it is possible they would eventually have to deal with the Walternate Observers. Too many variables trying to steal an alternate universe.

quote:

How did that Observer follow Liv to the altverse so easily? If the Obs can see someone disappear and automatically know where they went and be able to follow them, then their time jumping skills present even more of a problem than I originally thought. That was instantaneous and he followed her to the altverse in a heartbeat...and then another one (who wasn't even there) did the same thing. Why have they even been searching at all for these people when they can simply morph straight to where they are, no matter what universe they're in..?

Yup. Load of crap. BS meter exploded.
This post was edited on 2/20/15 at 8:50 pm
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/20/15 at 7:48 pm to
Does it make any sense that the observers would jump back to 2036?

Even with their future scenario ability, isn't there a chance they would kill someone who turned out to be an ancestor of the 2167 doctor? They wouldn't get a second chance. One error and boom, they are gone.

Any of the major changes they make to the world would could somehow change the experiments run by the guy in 2167. Seems to me the earliest they could jump back would be 2167.

Now I am changing my tune. Why risk their existence by making any changes to the timeline. They should have jumped to 10,000 AD Walternate universe and killed off mankind. Wouldn't mess with them at all and no risk. Just a pristine humanoid free planet to frack with.

Observers are idiots.

Posted by catholictigerfan
Member since Oct 2009
56009 posts
Posted on 2/21/15 at 8:22 am to
quote:

Even with their future scenario ability, isn't there a chance they would kill someone who turned out to be an ancestor of the 2167 doctor? They wouldn't get a second chance. One error and boom, they are gone.



if they kill the doctor the observers wouldn't exist anyway. Same with ancestor of doctors. The doctors must live for them to exist.

but in all seriousness with all the skill they have, they must be idiots to give actual humans a fighting chance. Someone with the ability to manipulate futures or pasts would be next to impossible to stop.
This post was edited on 2/21/15 at 8:26 am
Posted by catholictigerfan
Member since Oct 2009
56009 posts
Posted on 2/21/15 at 8:24 am to
quote:

Shouldn't the GodKid be able to travel through time on his own with an Observer device? Ought to be a piece of cake even without the device since he is supposedly so much more advanced than the Observers.



kid can't talk how would he convince them?
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/23/15 at 8:14 am to
I intentionally didn't watch the finale this weekend in order to continue discussion on the previous few episodes. I'll likely get to it over the next couple days.

I plan on responding to the posts on this page at some point today.
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/24/15 at 7:25 pm to
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/25/15 at 7:47 am to
quote:

This is one of my issues with seasons five. The observers could have taken over any time period they want. They could have went back in time and killed Walters father’s father’s father. Or least go to a time where the people would put up less of a fight

It's one of the problems with time travel in things like this. Obviously the Resistance is a worthy opponent, so they could very easily jump to a different time and go from there. I mean, it's literallty as easy as stepping through that teleport device thing to another point in time.
quote:

If peter wasn't the important boy why, did Peter's son Henry have to be erased?

I'm not sure if he "had to" be erased, but I'm not sure why he was. What's weird is how little of an impact Peter and Fauxliv's kid became. That was a pretty important thing for a while, and then all of a sudden he was just completely forgotten.
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/25/15 at 8:10 am to
quote:

How long have they been back? Once again, the observers sure aren't very observant since Pete and The Gang have been using power, lights and I would assume the bathroom in the old Harvard office for months. I find it somewhat odd, since they tripped an alarm the first time they were there, yet nobody has noticed the alarm was disabled. Nobody has noticed a power spike. Nobody has heard flushing toilets.

And there is literally a row of windows that is knee-high that overlooks the entire lab that they still haven't covered or blocked. Anybody glancing into those windows could easily see everything going on.
quote:

Here we go. Part of the reason I don't like the finale. Michael may have emotion and superior intellect but Michael was achieved THROUGH The Observers being born and refined. I don't see how you could just jump straight to Michael.

What do you mean jump straight to him? They know that he was "created." I thought the point was that he was the anomaly that proved that the Obs could exist and still have emotion and love and all that...they didn't have to be robotic people that just didn't give a frick about anything.

Also, thinking about that...what a shitty civilization. Being an Obs must suck. It's not like you do anything for fun, because "fun" isn't something that really exists for you. So you just basically sort of walk around all day tilting your head sideways trying to figure shite out. Sounds awful.
quote:

Nothing like a booby trap that FLASHES RED to warn trespassers of their impending death. That was just plain weak.

And not only that, but takes a solid 30 seconds to detonate. When you're trying to kill someone who can jump through time and space in a split second, that's not a very efficient attempt at murder.
quote:

They sure love them some monorail but do we ever see it?

We've seen it several times. Not only in city shots here and there, but isn't that what they got on that time when Peter first started seeing the Matrix when he and Walter were sitting together and Liv and Astrid were sitting further back?
quote:

They already knew the kid was an anomaly. He was already scheduled for termination. The whole testing Michael is stupid. Lets find out things we already knew when we stopped his maturation process and scheduled him for termination.

Yeah, a lot of things about S5 just feel sort of lazy sometimes.
quote:

Cokes, would you care to explain to me how anyone in the Walternate universe has any idea who Olivia is? Man, they really shite the bed with the whole Peter erasing himself from the universe plot. Ok, MAYBE and that is a real big maybe Olivia because of her treatment she was somehow able to MELD with both universes but they didn't even attempt to explain how anyone else can remember anything about the Peterverse.

Now we are just supposed to believe that everyone in the Fauxverse can remember Olivia? About 30 million plot problems... too many.... error...error.....




What do you mean? They remember her because they worked together on lots of shite. The last time we saw them, the portal between universes was closing for good, and they all said goodbye, and Link went to the altverse to stalk Fauxliv becuse he couldn't have real Liv. None of that changed...of course they still remember her.
quote:

I'm telling you, Windmark really blows at his job.

Windmark has all these super powers and yet he is as effective as Frank Burns.

The first observer watched Olivia phase out so maybe I get that he could hop. How did the second observer hop universes? If they are constantly connected or they can track each other then the captured Observers were bullshite in past episodes.


It really is amazing. It's sort of like the Empire losing to the Ewoks. Windmark is not only an Observer, so he's superior to humans in tons of ways, but he also has the tech which he has mastered. In fact, we clearly see that other Obs have the same capabilities. It not only allows them to escape death countless times by teleporting out of dangerous situations, but they can also jump to other places, different points in time, as well as different fricking UNIVERSES. Add that to the whole "calculating probabilities" thing where they can basically see, predict, and affect the future, and there is no chance they should ever struggle with any human resistance ever.

Yet despite all that, they are constantly getting caught, getting shot, leaving crime scenes where the humans would OBVIOUSLY return (like when Etta died or the lab with Nina and the boy), getting one-upped at damn near every turn. It doesn't make any sense, outside of just shoddy writing to make a TV show interesting. I mean shite, even when Peter had the tech in his head, he could use it better than most Obs, and could even affect Windmark's timeline at will. So we get him doing all kinds of elaborate shite to try to "Mouse Trap" his way into victory instead of just teleporting behind him and snapping his neck.

And don't get me wrong, I am enjoying S5 a lot, and really love the show. But there are things that are glaring when it comes to "Aw, come the frick on" with the show. And it seems to only be getting worse as the show progresses. One thing that makes Fringe such a great show is that it was always at least seemingly grounded in reality. Even with all of the outlandish shite they did, they had explanations for it that at least made a certain amount of sense to the viewers who weren't nuclear physicists. But in S5 it's been more about "Let's do this just because" and then rolling with that without any rhyme or reason than them getting to their endgame. In some instances the past was reset so nobody should remember shite, but in other instances it wasn't and people can remember everything. Peter never existed, but then...just kidding, yes he did. And Peter just wants his Olivia back, but just kidding again...it was really his Olivia all along. shite like that.

Wasn't S5 sort of unexpected when it aired? So could this be because they weren't really expecting to get another 13 episodes, so they had to fill them with a lot of bullshite to reach the number of episodes? Seems like most of this could've been taken care of with a two hour movie.
This post was edited on 2/25/15 at 8:13 am
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/25/15 at 8:16 am to
quote:

They didn't just remove the tech. Donald said they experimented on him. Called it reversion therapy, so they devolved him.

Okay, then that makes sense.

Also, since a lot of this show sort of runs together for me...whatever happened with September getting shot and dying? Did that get reset somehow? How is he alive and well (and human) in the future..?
quote:

He ran the numbers. Remember he is smarter than anyone. I assume he ran the scenarios and the only way for all of them to escape was for him to be captured.

I get that, but he literally stepped out as the doors closed. So they had basically already gotten away.
quote:

Their universe was damaged so perhaps it was too hard to run the numbers over there. Also, it is possible they would eventually have to deal with the Walternate Observers. Too many variables trying to steal an alternate universe.

I can dig that. That at least makes some sense and could be a reason they didn't invade, even though they clearly can jump there any time they want to.
Posted by CocomoLSU
Inside your dome.
Member since Feb 2004
150565 posts
Posted on 2/25/15 at 8:20 am to
quote:

but in all seriousness with all the skill they have, they must be idiots to give actual humans a fighting chance. Someone with the ability to manipulate futures or pasts would be next to impossible to stop.

And not just manipulate them, but teleport jump to those points in time in less than a second.

They would (or at least should) be literally impossible to stop. Any time something bad happened, they could simply jump back before it happened and correct it/stop it. Oh, the resistance somehow killed Windmark? NBD, let's just jump back to last Thursday and correct that shite.

And what sort of bugs me is that they already sort of alluded to this on the show. They threw the antimatter device into that portal and that was supposed to create all kinds of havoc on the other end and disrupt them for decades...and then a few minutes later a new portal popped up and it was business as usual since, you know, time travel and all.
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/25/15 at 8:42 am to
quote:

What do you mean jump straight to him? They know that he was "created." I thought the point was that he was the anomaly that proved that the Obs could exist and still have emotion and love and all that...they didn't have to be robotic people that just didn't give a frick about anything.


Nope. Michael was created with Observer DNA. It took the refinement over hundreds of years to get to Michael so I don't see how Michael proves anything other than the project worked. At some point the observer lack of emotion leads to a superior brain at which point emotion could be added back. As I said, I'm a stickler on this. Michael was not a human that had intellect and emotion. He was an OBSERVER with DNA from normal run of the mill emotionless parents. You could not ever get to Michael without first changing humanity into observers.
Posted by TigerMyth36
River Ridge
Member since Nov 2005
39728 posts
Posted on 2/25/15 at 8:56 am to
quote:

What do you mean? They remember her because they worked together on lots of shite. The last time we saw them, the portal between universes was closing for good, and they all said goodbye, and Link went to the altverse to stalk Fauxliv becuse he couldn't have real Liv. None of that changed...of course they still remember her.


Yeah, I was so busy bitching about season 5 I forgot the Peterverse disappeared in seasons 3 and 4 was the 2 working together.
first pageprev pagePage 59 of 62Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram