MMO that you have played and your opinion of them

It's hard to find a MMO that can keep my attention, hell I go back and play EQ for a month or two every year because it's my first love, WoW is in 2nd place and I play it for a month every couple of years. I would love to find a MMO that could keep my attention.

Tried:

Everquest 2 - I love the crafting and house "building" in this game and it's fun but after a while you need a guild to progress.

Age of Conan - The best starting area in any MMO, but gets muddied after that.

RIFT - This kept me for a few months but then lost interest.

Warhammer - It was OK but didn't keep me past the initial month.

Atlantica Online - This was a great game and it ranks third on my MMO list, this game did so many things different than any other MMO and they were FUN, but you need a good guild holding a town to make it fun.

Lord of the Rings - This is fourth on my list but I always hit a wall around level 35, very good up to that point and did a good job up to that point.

Guild Wars - Joined late to the game and it was fun for a while.

Guild Wars 2 - Very good game but the crafting was too damn hard to figure out, still put a few months into it and enjoyed it, I still fire it up once a year.

D&D Online - had a lot of fun in this but it became cash shop heavy to progress.

Star Wars the old Republic - Fun game and I still play it for a while every year or two, but still not endgame that matters, and to experience different character stories you have to trudge through the same areas every time.

Star Trek - Didn't get past a few days in this.

Dare Ages of Camelot - I regret missing this game but I was busy playing EQ, tried it for a bit after the fact and it was too late.

Original Star Wars MMO - Missed the before NGE ruined the game because I was playing EQ.

Elder Scrolls - Played the Beta and wasn't impressed, but thinking of playing again.

Neverwinter - This is still a good game that I play every couple of years, but after time it's hard to catch up with the updates because you feel lost. Still worth playing.

Everquest Landmark - This was fun, but the building was too technical.

Rust and games like this where your shite can get wiped out and you have to start from scratch don't do much for me, I have tried a few.

I am sure I am missing some and will add them later if somene joggs my memory, I have tried a lot of the Asian MMO's but none of them are memorable, I have never tried a Final Fantasy MMO because of the reported grind.

Game others have reminded me of:

Vangaurd - Was supposed to be the next EQ and was fun but buggy as hell and didn't stick.

City of Heroes - It was fun but I have never been into the super hero genre. It was fun though.

EVE - Hold shite the learning curve in that game was too much for me and I suck at flying games.

Definace - It was fun but nothing stood out for me and didn't keep my interest.