re: Rotten Tomatoes Ranks the Best Superhero Movies of All Time

quote:

---

Wonder Woman shouldn't even be in the top 10

---

Eh I'd put it in my top 10, it's a really solid flim.

I didn’t find WW to be preachy by even the slightest bit. I enjoyed it.

Winter Soldier belongs at either #1 or #2. It would still be a great movie if it wasn’t a Captain America movie.

Incredibles is terribly underrated.

LEGO Batman is overrated. It’s good and I appreciated how self aware it was, but LEGO Movie was more fun and vastly rewatchable.

Avengers is just a well done movie. The stakes are real, the victory is in doubt. And the group shot for the first time while the theme blares in the background gave me silly goosebumps the first time i saw it.

Superman belongs on here somewhere. As does Spider-Man 2. Homecoming was perfect for the MCU but not as good as 2

quote:

---

WONDER WOMAN (2017)

#1

---

Wonder Woman over Logan is a travesty of the highest order

I went back to the beginning of the list to find out how it was made.

quote:

---

It’s a bird! It’s a plane! It’s Rotten Tomatoes’ list of the 50 best superhero movies of all time, ranked by adjusted Tomatometer with at least 20 reviews each

---

"The Adjusted Score comes from a formula (Bayesian) that we use that accounts for variation in the number of reviews per movie."

quote:

---

"The Adjusted Score comes from a formula (Bayesian) that we use that accounts for variation in the number of reviews per movie."

---

Translation: We created an equation that made sure WW was at the top.

quote:

---

Eh I'd put it in my top 10, it's a really solid flim.

---

If "solid" films make the top 10 of their respected genre, I think that says more about said genre.

I really don't understand the Wonder Woman Hype. Good acting from Gadot, but everything about the film is so bland. It's the SAME formula we've seen in EVERY superhero film of the last decade. The final battle sequence was terrible.

Terrible list...TDK is #1.

I'm so behind on watching super hero movies....I still haven't seen Winter Soldier or any of the Avengers after that.

quote:

---

Also, did they even rate Watchmen!?

---

they probably started watching it, realized they were an hour and a half in and still had 2 hours left to this boring movie and quite watching it so no, they didn't even rate it.


The Incredibles isn't a superhero movie. It is, but it's a Pixar movie, and it's genre is Pixar, not superhero. Stupid to compare it to these movies.

Winter Soldier is way too low.
and everyone knows The Dark Knight is #1. You immediately discredit yourself by not having it #1.