Andrew Luck went to a 2-14 team and then went 11-5 without his HC for a portion of the year and made the playoffs as a rookie.
Yeah, whatever would the Colts have done without Andrew Luck's 54.1% and 18 interceptions. Luck and Newton's rookie years were almost similar, only the Colts had a better team
. And if you're going to throw out the Colts missing their head coach, make sure you mention that lockout that occured in 2011. Cam Newton (rookie year)
310/517, 60.0%, 4,051 yards, 21 touchdowns, 17 interceptions
126 carries, 706 yards, 14 touchdowns Andrew Luck (rookie year)
339/627, 54.1%, 4,374 yards, 23 touchdowns, 18 interceptions
62 carries, 255 yards, 5 touchdowns