Started By
Message

$200 for a bourbon/whiskey collection - what do you pick?

Posted on 11/17/22 at 8:43 pm
Posted by BMoney
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2005
16268 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 8:43 pm
So inspired by today's Bourbon Junkies video, what would you choose if you were tasked to start a bourbon/whiskey collection with $200? After watching their video, I'd change up the rules slightly.

- You have to pick no fewer than 5 bottles
- All bottles must be 750ml or greater
- Everything must be at least semi-regularly available to you
- Use retail prices in your area. This is pretty subjective, but use your judgement here
- Go with price before tax since everywhere is different

Here are my picks:

1. Buffalo Trace ($25) - I can get it for $22, but most places have it for a few bucks more.

2. Wild Turkey Rare Breed ($50) - Really hard to beat this one.

3. Old Forester Rye ($30) - My favorite whiskey to make an Old Fashioned with, and still great to drink neat.

4. Old Forester 1910 ($55) - Love this bottle. Thought about Woodford Reserve Double Oaked at a similar price point, but I think I like this one better.

5. Elijah Craig Small Batch ($25) - This is still a really nice daily drinker.

These 5 bottles come in at $185. I could have gone with something else a little pricier than the EC or BT, but I think this would be a great starter bourbon collection.
Posted by calcotron
Member since Nov 2007
8253 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 8:51 pm to
Old Grandad 114 - $29
Devils River Barrel Strength 115 - $33
Wheel Horse 101 Sour Mas - $33
Chattanooga 111 cask - $40
Rebel Cask Strength 120 proof - $60


Might swap out one of the cheaper ones for Johnny Drum at $33. Plenty of good choices.
Posted by t00f
Not where you think I am
Member since Jul 2016
89788 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 8:52 pm to
1: EC small batch -$25
2: Sagamore double Oak -$55
3: Early Times Bottled In Bond -$25
4: Eagle Rare 10 -$30
5: Wild Turkey 101 -$22
Total=$157
Posted by Zappas Stache
Utility Muffin Research Kitchen
Member since Apr 2009
38671 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 9:02 pm to
Evan Williams Black label $16
WT 101 $32
Russell 10 year $35
Still Austin cask $55
Penelope Architect $58

Posted by BigDropper
Member since Jul 2009
7625 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 9:14 pm to
8 bottles of Buffalo Trace ($25)

$200
Posted by SingleMalt1973
Member since Feb 2022
11903 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 9:19 pm to
1-WT Rare Breed-$49

2-Russell’s Reserve 10-$39

3-KC Single Barrel pick-$59

4-Wilderness Trail 6yr -$69
This post was edited on 11/17/22 at 9:21 pm
Posted by Epic Cajun
Lafayette, LA
Member since Feb 2013
32424 posts
Posted on 11/17/22 at 9:23 pm to
Rare Breed Rye-$60
Noah’s Mill-$50
Four Roses SiB-$40
Eagle Rare-$30
Sazerac Rye-$20
This post was edited on 11/17/22 at 9:37 pm
Posted by Rize
Spring Texas
Member since Sep 2011
15773 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 7:25 am to
Russel’s 10
4 Roses Small Batch select
4 Roses Single Barrel
Buffalo Trace
Isaac Bowman Port Barrel
Posted by LSUBoo
Knoxville, TN
Member since Mar 2006
101917 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 7:47 am to
Can't find Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, or Sazerac on the shelves here, which sucks.

Actual prices from the local liquor store...
Woodford Double Oaked - $55
Old Forester Rye - $24
Chattanooga 111 - $45
Laphroaig 10-Year Single Malt - $59
Evan Williams BiB - $17

Exactly $200 before tax. (well, 5 cents less thanks to rounding...)

Posted by Big Chipper
Charlotte, NC
Member since Sep 2008
2775 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 7:56 am to
8 handles of Evan Williams black @ $183.60 ($22.95 * 8) + sales tax = $198.29.
Posted by LNCHBOX
70448
Member since Jun 2009
84068 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 8:26 am to
quote:

- Everything must be at least semi-regularly available to you
quote:

1: EC small batch -$25
2: Sagamore double Oak -$55
3: Early Times Bottled In Bond -$25
4: Eagle Rare 10 -$30

5: Wild Turkey 101 -$22
I guess you could argue over what "semi-regularly" means, but I wouldn't say these available at retail often enough to qualify for this exercise.

My list would be:

Wild Turkey Rare Breed $57
Woodford Reserve $29
Old Forrester Rye 100 proof $30
Penelope Toasted $63
Evan Williams BIB $16

Total $195 (these are Total Wine prices, you can do better)
Posted by DomincDecoco
of no fixed abode
Member since Oct 2018
10861 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 8:27 am to
1 bottle of Middleton Very Rare
Posted by BMoney
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2005
16268 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 8:40 am to
quote:

I guess you could argue over what "semi-regularly" means, but I wouldn't say these available at retail often enough to qualify for this exercise.


I picked up a bottle of Early Times BiB at Total Wine in BR a couple weeks ago. First time I've ever seen it here. Not sure if it will become a regular thing or not.
Posted by juice4lsu
Member since Dec 2007
3695 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 9:13 am to
Buffalo Trace - $25
Michter's American - $45
Monkey Shoulder - $30
Redbreast 12 - $63
Four Roses Single Barrel - $38

I'm $1 over, but I think this is a pretty balanced collection.
Posted by tke_swamprat
Houma, LA
Member since Aug 2004
9758 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 9:29 am to
Four Roses SIB - 40
Russell's 10yr - 40
Maker's store pick - 60
Buffalo Trace - 25
Coopers 100 - 35
This post was edited on 11/18/22 at 10:26 am
Posted by AlxTgr
Kyre Banorg
Member since Oct 2003
81616 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 9:54 am to
Buffalo Trace
Country Smooth
Rare Breed
Elijah Craig SB
Heaven's Door Tenn Bourbon
Posted by Epic Cajun
Lafayette, LA
Member since Feb 2013
32424 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 10:19 am to
quote:

I guess you could argue over what "semi-regularly" means, but I wouldn't say these available at retail often enough to qualify for this exercise.

I was on the fence about Eagle Rare, initially I had Buffalo Trace because of the “rarity” of Eagle Rare, but saw that Toof went with Eagle Rare so I followed suit. I can still pretty much get it when if I need it, but it’s not super common. It’s not as scarce as EH Taylor or even Blanton’s, which is kinda where I’d draw the line on availability.
Posted by AlxTgr
Kyre Banorg
Member since Oct 2003
81616 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 10:35 am to
quote:

Eagle Rare
The only bottle I have found in the last three years I had to win a raffle for. I had gotten pretty spoiled because my bookkeeper used to contact Hokus early in the year and beg for a bottle to get me for Christmas. Unfortunately, she moved.
Posted by LSUballs
RayVegas LA
Member since Feb 2008
37741 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 10:40 am to
Just leaving Savannah. Eagle Rare everywhere. It's scarce as hell in NELA
This post was edited on 11/18/22 at 11:05 am
Posted by tke_swamprat
Houma, LA
Member since Aug 2004
9758 posts
Posted on 11/18/22 at 11:05 am to
Was it listed at $30 or marked up a ton?
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram