Started By
Message

The Official Comic Book Hero Tournament Round I (Results)

Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:33 am
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:33 am
The Rules:

1.) This is a two sided bracket. Each side contains 64 comic characters.

2.) The left side of the bracket will be Heroes the right side of the bracket will be villains.

3.) Each bracket will be comprised of 26 Marvel characters, 26 DC characters, and 12 misc comic/novel characters.

4.) Once all of the characters have been selected, the names will be entered into a random generator and spit out 1-64. The match-ups will be set regular seed style (1 vs. 64, 2 vs. 63, etc.) Please note that the number does not represent their seed, but instead the number they drew.

*** Do not be surprised to see Cyclops vs. Rick Grimes in Round I

5.) The voting system will be a simple check mark system. You will simply select the name of the character you think would win each match-up. I will go off of the general consensus. If there is an instance where the voting for a particular match-up is close, I will open the floor for members to make their case for who should move on. I will have the final say in such situations, but I promise to be as fair and impartial as I can.

6.) All voters are asked to put bias to the side. We must assume that these match-ups are completely random (As if it is the first time each character has encountered the other character.) Hopefully this will cut down on some of the knighting... cough Batman cough...

***So it would probably be safe to say that Batman would not be walking around with the Muramasa Sword.

***In the case where you have characters who cannot be killed by normal means (Wolverine, Deadpool, Thor) then a knockout or incapacitation will count
-Hulk Vs. Thor (whoever could knock the other one out first or incapacitate)
-Wolverine Vs. Deadpool (Same)
-These are just general examples

7.) Each character will be considered to be at their peak with no additional augmentation.

***Example: Cable w/ his technorganic virus under control, or cyclops w/ full control of his optic blast. No Nova with the Worldmind & Full Nova Force or Doom with The Beyonder's powers.
This post was edited on 3/27/14 at 9:31 am
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:33 am to
Final Hero Roster

Marvel Heroes

1.) Beta Ray Bill
2.) Black Bolt
3.) Black Panther
4.) Cable
5.) Captain America
6.) Cyclops
7.) Dare Devil
8.) Deadpool
9.) Dr. Strange
10.)Ghost Rider
11.)Hulk
12.)Human Torch, The
13.)Iceman
14.)Iron-Man
15.)Jean Grey
16.)Kitty Pryde
17.)Ms. Marvel
18.)Nova
19.)Psylocke
20.)Punisher
21.)Silver Surfer
22.)Spider-Man
23.)Storm
24.)Thor
25.)Vision
26.)Wolverine

Finalized DC Heroes

DC Heroes

1.) Aquaman
2.) Batman
3.) Big Barda
4.) Black Canary
5.) Black Lightening
6.) Blue Bettle
7.) Captain Atom
8.) Constantine
9.) Cyborg
10.)Dr. Fate
11.)Firestorm
12.)Flash (Barry Allen)
13.)Green Arrow
14.)Green Latern (Hal Jordan)
15.)Hawkman
16.)Martian Manhunter
17.)Nightwing
18.)Power Girl/Super Girl
19.)Raven
20.)Red Tornado
21.)Shazam/Captain Marvel
22.)Starfire
23.)Swamp Thing
24.)Superman
25.)Wonder Woman
26.)Zatanna

Misc Heroes

1.) Billy Butcher
2.) Hellboy
3.) Hit Girl
4.) Jesse Custer (Preacher)
5.) Judge Dredd
6.) Leonardo
7.) Marv
8.) Michonne
9.) Sara Pezzini (Witchblade)
10.)Spawn
11.)Wesley Gibson
12.)Vampirella
This post was edited on 3/25/14 at 11:37 am
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:33 am to
Bracket

Match #1
place #1: Shazam
place #2: Martian Manhunter
Match #2
place #1: Storm
place #2: Deadpool
Match #3
place #1: Power Girl
place #2: Big Barda
Match #4
place #1: Psylocke
place #2: Cyborg
Match #5
place #1: Vision
place #2: Green Latern (Hal Jordan)
Match #6
place #1: Aquaman
place #2: Cyclops
Match #7
place #1: Hit Girl
place #2: Black Bolt
Match #8
place #1: Jesse Custer (Preacer)
place #2: Flash (Barry Allen)
Match #9
place #1: Hulk (Planet Hulk) Surprised Me
place #2: Silver Surfer
Match #10
place #1: Captain America Hurt me to lose Nightwing
place #2: Nightwing
Match #11
place #1: Superman
place #2: Beta Ray Bill
Match #12
place #1: Swamp Thing
place #2: Iron-Man
Match #13
place #1: Punisher
place #2: Vampirella
Match #14
place #1: Kitty Pryde
place #2: Spider-Man
Match #15
place #1: Blue Bettle (Jamie Reyes)
place #2: Green Arrow
Match #16
place #1: Black Canary
place #2: Spawn
Match #17
place #1: Constantine
place #2: Thor
Match #18
place #1: Hawkman
place #2: Cable
Match #19
place #1: Michonne
place #2: Hellboy
Match #20
place #1: Starfire
place #2: Jean Grey
Match #21
place #1: Raven
place #2: Batman
Match #22
place #1: Nova
place #2: Zatanna
Match #23
place #1: Sara Pezzini (Witchblade)
place #2: Black Lightening
Match #24
place #1: Billy Butcher
place #2: Captain Atom
Match #25
place #1: Leonardo
place #2: Ms. Marvel
Match #26
place #1: Wesley Gibson
place #2: Ghost Rider
Match #27
place #1: Judge Dredd
place #2: Red Tornado
Match #28
place #1: Black Panther
place #2: Dr. Strange
Match #29
place #1: Wonder Woman
place #2: Dare Devil
Match #30
place #1: Marv
place #2: Firestorm
Match #31
place #1: Iceman
place #2: Wolverine
Match #32
place #1: Human Torch, The
place #2: Dr. Fate
This post was edited on 3/27/14 at 9:17 am
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:33 am to
Brackett

Match Ups were completely randomized. Rules have been set. Please try to be as fair and unbiased as possible.

Voting for Round I will be open for the next 24 hours.

Begin!
This post was edited on 3/25/14 at 12:07 pm
Posted by illuminatic
Manipulating politicans&rappers
Member since Sep 2012
6962 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:47 am to
Match #1
place #1:
place #2: Martian Manhunter
Match #2
place #1:
place #2: Deadpool
Match #3
place #1: Power Girl
place #2:
Match #4
place #1: Psylocke
place #2:
Match #5
place #1:
place #2: Green Lantern
Match #6
place #1:
place #2: Cyclops
Match #7
place #1:
place #2: Black Bolt
Match #8
place #1:
place #2: Flash (Barry Allen)
Match #9
place #1:
place #2: Silver Surfer
Match #10
place #1: Captain America
place #2:
Match #11
place #1: Superman
place #2:
Match #12
place #1: Swamp Thing
place #2:
Match #13
place #1:
place #2: Vampirella
Match #14
place #1:
place #2: Spider-Man
Match #15
place #1:
place #2: Green Arrow
Match #16
place #1:
place #2: Spawn
Match #17
place #1: Constantine
place #2:
Match #18
place #1:
place #2: Cable
Match #19
place #1:
place #2: Hellboy
Match #20
place #1:
place #2: Jean Grey
Match #21
place #1: Raven
place #2:
Match #22
place #1: Nova
place #2:
Match #23
place #1: Sara Pezzini (Witchblade)
place #2:
Match #24
place #1:
place #2: Captain Atom
Match #25
place #1:
place #2: Ms. Marvel
Match #26
place #1:
place #2: Ghost Rider
Match #27
place #1:
place #2: Red Tornado
Match #28
place #1:
place #2: Dr. Strange
Match #29
place #1: Wonder Woman
place #2:
Match #30
place #1:
place #2: Firestorm
Match #31
place #1: Iceman
place #2:
Match #32
place #1:
place #2: Dr. Fate
This post was edited on 3/25/14 at 4:39 pm
Posted by fr33manator
Baton Rouge
Member since Oct 2010
123923 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 11:51 am to
Spawn wins it all
Posted by BlacknGold
He Hate Me
Member since Mar 2009
12040 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:01 pm to
so we arent trying to match up similarly leveled heroes?
Posted by Scruffy
Kansas City
Member since Jul 2011
72023 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:03 pm to
There are some good matchups in there. Not bad.
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:08 pm to
quote:

so we arent trying to match up similarly leveled heroes?


Completely random, we established that point!

Not trying to be an arse of course
Posted by BlacknGold
He Hate Me
Member since Mar 2009
12040 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:09 pm to
haha thats cool. there are going to be some upsets this round i think. some fan favorites already pitted against one another.
Posted by Methuselah
On da Riva
Member since Jan 2005
23350 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:20 pm to
So, how do we vote again?
Posted by Darkknight
Member since Mar 2012
1415 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:24 pm to
Some of these matchups are a tough call, which are the ones I like.

For consistency purposes and to make things easier on you, what method you want for everyone to vote?

AND, much appreciate you setting this up
Posted by kingbob
Sorrento, LA
Member since Nov 2010
67006 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:28 pm to
Sazam
Deadpool
Power Girl
Cyborg
Green Lantern
Cyclops
Hit Girl
Flash
Hulk
Captain America
Superman
Iron Man
Punisher
Spider Man
Green Arrow
Spawn
Thor
Hawkman
Hellboy
Starfire
Batman
Nova
Witchblade
Billy Butcher
Ms Marvel
Ghost Rider
Judge Dredd
Dr. Strange
Wonder Woman
Firestorm
Wolverine
The Human Torch
Posted by Murray
Member since Aug 2008
14414 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:32 pm to
Match #1
place #2: Martian Manhunter
Match #2
place #2: Deadpool
Match #3
place #1: Power Girl
Match #4
place #2: Cyborg
Match #5
place #2: Green Latern (Hal Jordan)
Match #6
place #2: Cyclops
Match #7
place #2: Black Bolt
Match #8
place #2: Flash (Barry Allen)
Match #9
place #1: Hulk(if smart Hulk I choose Hulk)
place #2: Silver Surfer(if dumb Hulk, SS wins)
Match #10
place #1: Captain America
Match #11
place #1: Superman
Match #12
place #1: Swamp Thing
Match #13
place #1: Punisher
Match #14
place #2: Spider-Man
Match #15
place #2: Blue Beetle
Match #16
place #2: Spawn
Match #17
place #2: Thor
Match #18
place #2: Cable
Match #19
place #2: Hellboy
Match #20
place #2: Jean Grey
Match #21
place #2: Batman
Match #22
place #2: Zatanna
Match #23
place #2: Black Lightening
Match #24
place #2: Captain Atom
Match #25
place #2: Ms. Marvel
Match #26
place #2: Ghost Rider
Match #27
place #2: Red Tornado
Match #28
place #2: Dr. Strange
Match #29
place #1: Wonder Woman
Match #30
place #2: Firestorm
Match #31
place #1: Iceman
Match #32
place #2: Dr. Fate


There were some good matchups in there. I really liked the Iceman vs Wolverine because that means, that hairy little bitch is out in the first round.

ETA:

The Blue Beetle is not Ted Kord but the most recent version which is basically a better version of Iron Man.

Vote changed.

This post was edited on 3/26/14 at 8:15 am
Posted by Murray
Member since Aug 2008
14414 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:32 pm to
quote:

AND, much appreciate you setting this up


Ditto
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:33 pm to
quote:

So, how do we vote again?


Well we ruled out debating so, just go through and select your choice for each match-up and list them.

Ex.

Match Up 1
Shazam

Match Up 2
...

Match Up 3
....

If a match-up is very tight then I will open up to debate among the posters and make the final decision.
Posted by Murray
Member since Aug 2008
14414 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:36 pm to
You may wanna clarify which Hulk we're using as that makes a big difference.

Hulk Smash
Joe Fixit(Grey Hulk)
Smart Hulk
Planet Hulk(Kind of Smart Hulk but less in control and more aggressive)
Posted by imjustafatkid
Alabama
Member since Dec 2011
50304 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:38 pm to
quote:

Match #1
Shazam

Match #2
Deadpool

Match #3
Big Barda

Match #4
Psylocke

Match #5
Green Lantern

Match #6
Aquaman

Match #7
Hit Girl

Match #8
Flash (Barry Allen)

Match #9
Silver Surfer

Match #10
Nightwing

Match #11
Superman

Match #12
Swamp Thing

Match #13
Vampirella

Match #14
Spider-Man

Match #15
Green Arrow

Match #16
Spawn

Match #17
Thor

Match #18
Cable

Match #19
Hellboy

Match #20
Jean Grey

Match #21
Batman

Match #22
Zatanna

Match #23
Sara Pezzini (Witchblade)

Match #24
Captain Atom

Match #25
Leonardo

Match #26
Ghost Rider

Match #27
Red Tornado

Match #28
Dr. Strange

Match #29
Wonder Woman

Match #30
Firestorm

Match #31
Wolverine

Match #32
Dr. Fate
This post was edited on 3/25/14 at 7:29 pm
Posted by Darkknight
Member since Mar 2012
1415 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:43 pm to
quote:

Well we ruled out debating so


But since voting is open for 24 hours, I can convince someone to change their vote before the time is up, huh??

For example, if Murray and I discuss why he picked Manhunter over Shazam, and I convince him that Shazam would beat Manhunter, then Murray can go back and change his vote with 1 hour left in the 1st round correct?
Posted by bigpetedatiga
Alexandria, LA
Member since Aug 2009
8623 posts
Posted on 3/25/14 at 12:45 pm to
Lets go with Planet Hulk version
Jump to page
Page 1 2 3 4 5 ... 18
Jump to page
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 18Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram