OB Dog Discipline Question

My Pop is keeping my brother's dog for the week while brother and family are at the beach. Dad goes out to cut grass and leaves the dog in the camp (my folks have pretty much moved to the camp since retirement). He comes back in after 30 minutes to find the dog has pulled back and shredded about 30 sf of carpet around the door. I went up yesterday afternoon with my daughter to shoot some cans (beer cans, not Afri-cans, Mexi-cans, or any other kinds of cans) and saw the floor.

If you were my Pop, would the OB:

1. Make brother pay to replace the floor.

2. Make the repairs and tell brother not to worry about the cost.

3. Shoot the dog.


In all seriousness, this dog has done stuff like this at its own house dozens of times. She has eaten about $2,000 of my sister-in-law's shoes over a 3 yr period. I told him to haul the dog off (dead or alive, doesn't matter to me) and tell my brother it ran away. Since I know the OB is borderline OT sometimes and gives a shite about the "feelings" of animals I won't give you the option of hauling it out into the country to let it survive on its own.