Regarding America's Geography: True or False? | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
TigerPride10
Columbia Fan
Seoul, Korea
Member since Jul 2007
9485 posts

Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


The United States is as wealthy, deomocratic, and powerful as it is because of its geography.

I just finished up Robert Kaplan's book, The Revenge of Geography, and he alludes to this several times throughout. His thesis was that democracy and a free market economy can only flourish in a country whose borders are secure. He gives examples of Great Britain in comparison to Germany... The former is an island nation, apart from the struggles of continental Europe after the Hundred Year's War. The latter was a land-based power with powerful empires on either side. Democracy only came to a united Germany when its borders were secured by the strongest military alliance in the world. For the United States, he argues his claim by pointing to the fact that our only real threat along our border in the past 200 years has been Mexico. Our borders also touch the two most important oceans in the world.

Thoughts?



This post was edited on 1/29 at 10:39 pm



Back to top
Share:
JLSIX
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Apr 2010
23106 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


It sure helped. So, true.





Back to top
geauxtigers87
USA Fan
NOLA
Member since Mar 2011
6661 posts
 Online 

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


true, but being some badass mofo's helps too





Back to top
joshnorris14
Florida Fan
Florida
Member since Jan 2009
21176 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

The United States is as wealthy, deomocratic, and powerful as it is because of its geography.


False.






Back to top
Tiger Authority
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2007
29475 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?








Back to top
Cold Pizza
Ohio State Fan
Member since Sep 2011
7639 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


Being founded by a bunch of white men with gigantic balls was the key.





Back to top
AlaTiger
LSU Fan
Alabama
Member since Aug 2006
12740 posts
 Online 

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


False.

It was Culture that did it.

That culture is being systematically destroyed, so expect the success to decline.







Back to top
Decatur
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2007
17547 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


Geography is a very big factor, maybe the biggest. There is a reason people focus on geopolitics.





Back to top
Decatur
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2007
17547 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

It was Culture that did it.


Which culture?






Back to top
cwill
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Jan 2005
23879 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


It's a compelling hypothesis....I think it was also helpful that it was a place where Europeans could step out of and escape the limiting environs of their home countries plus the British roots.





Back to top
HailHailtoMichigan!
Michigan Fan
Mission Viejo, CA
Member since Mar 2012
10570 posts
 Online 

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


This is the opposite of the Turner thesis, which stated that settlement of new land/frontiers is the engine for democracy.





Back to top
TigerPride10
Columbia Fan
Seoul, Korea
Member since Jul 2007
9485 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

False.


Then what's your reason?






Back to top
TigerPride10
Columbia Fan
Seoul, Korea
Member since Jul 2007
9485 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

It was Culture that did it.


What culture are you referring to specifically? The heterogeneous one? Or the Anglo-Saxon traditions, that aren't really American in the first place?






Back to top
JLSIX
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Apr 2010
23106 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


It's clearly not the only reason, but without our geography we would have never gotten as powerful as we have become.





Back to top
TigerPride10
Columbia Fan
Seoul, Korea
Member since Jul 2007
9485 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

This is the opposite of the Turner thesis, which stated that settlement of new land/frontiers is the engine for democracy.


I've read The Frontier, and my objections were twofold. First, how do you quantify an experience? Second, how come the same argument cannot be applied to other land-based empires throughout history, namely Russia?

Turner was a product of his generation.






Back to top
TigerPride10
Columbia Fan
Seoul, Korea
Member since Jul 2007
9485 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

It's clearly not the only reason


What other reasons would you suggest? Remember that the geopolitical argument posits that culture, democracy, innovation, etc. cannot exist without a secure border.






Back to top
joshnorris14
Florida Fan
Florida
Member since Jan 2009
21176 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:

Then what's your reason?


A relatively high level of individual liberty.






Back to top
cwill
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Jan 2005
23879 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


I don't think it can be boiled down to one reason....but it makes sense that isolation could have lent a hand.

ETA: what about Japan? Other island nations aside from GB? Mexico's borders are secure....clearly it's more.... Something about GB and its colonies always stand out IMHO.



This post was edited on 1/29 at 11:12 pm


Back to top
M. A. Ryland
LSU Fan
silver spring, MD
Member since Dec 2005
891 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


quote:


The United States is as wealthy, deomocratic, and powerful as it is because of its geography.


False.
The geography certainly helped, but I think a bigger factor is the people.
Remember, America was populated by people willing to cross an ocean to a strange land for a chance to build a life from scratch. That was some pretty serious self-selection for hard-working risk takers.






Back to top
Decatur
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2007
17547 posts

re: Regarding America's Geography: True or False?


I think secure borders may be a necessary condition for a lasting democracy, as nations with unsecure borders obviously see more regime change and therefore aren't sufficiently stable to maintain a democracy (this is just speaking generally). I don't think that a democracy necessarily rises just because a nation has secure borders.


This post was edited on 1/29 at 11:10 pm


Back to top


Back to top




//