DL recruiting question | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
billyholawboy
Southern Miss Fan
Denham Springs
Member since Dec 2007
307 posts

DL recruiting question


Downs is gone & it's prob 50/50 if Logan stays or goes. If he leaves, we've got Freak & Ego starting, w/ Mickey J. & Quentin T. rotating in. Seems a little weak & one injury to Freak/Ego away from being the weakest position group on the team. (plus I wouldn't be shocked if Freak was gone after '13 & there's chatter about Tevin Lawson not qualifying.)

Any gurus/insiders a little curious as to why we're not going balls out for a stud juco DT? I like that we saw the need & went & got Q. Leslie @ WR. Any Claude Wroten/Akeem Hicks out there we should've pressed hard for a signature?







Back to top
Share:
TheTruthPolice
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Aug 2010
305 posts

re: DL recruiting question


Because JC Dt's are first off hard to evaluate. Chances are for every Wroten you get there will be three Toran Williams. Toran Williams was suppose to be the stud JC DT in the 01 class that we fought UF for in a heated battle. He never made the three deep even after red-shirting his first year. I can promise you if Mickey Johnson and Quentin Thomas were playing in JC the past two years they would be ranked in the top 15-25 players at worst. Toby Johnson is the only DT that has a chance to be LSU material next year, and I doubt he is better than Ego. Try selling a battle for second string to a JUCO player. Its more risk than reward unless you see somebody you really really like.





Back to top
Hot Carl
LSU Fan
Where I want to be
Member since Dec 2005
37772 posts

re: DL recruiting question


I don't care if they're JUCO or true FR, we desperately need DTs who.are ready to play next year and play well. If Logan leaves, we are extremely thin there. At a position that used to be the strength of the team. let's face it, Freak has not been the stud we expected yet, and Ego has been underwhelming. And we're counting on QT and Mickey to provide quality 2nd string reps after having never sniffed the field? DT--hell, the entire DL has questions not only at starters, but also depth. We need to hit on those rare FR that can contribute immediately and Moffittneeds to light a fire under some assed already here.





Back to top
Hot Carl
LSU Fan
Where I want to be
Member since Dec 2005
37772 posts

re: DL recruiting question


Our success may rely on how much of a jump Rasco and Freak make. Seems most of our All-American types have made more noise in their first 2 years. Color me skeptical.





Back to top
Stagg8
Rice Fan
Houston
Member since Jan 2005
10885 posts

re: DL recruiting question


quote:

Color me skeptical.


Depth is a pretty serious concern. But, I wouldn't be surprised to see Danielle Hunter get Mingo/Montgomery hype in the future. Kid is going to be good.






Back to top
judge
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Jan 2008
276 posts

re: DL recruiting question


Downs has given valiant effort, but no of SEC calibur. The thing that disturbs me about him seeing so much pt is; what does that say about Freak?





Back to top
bearhc
LSU Fan
Member since Sep 2009
1215 posts

re: DL recruiting question


JOhnson is not the player he was hyped to be;he isn't bad, but he is not a dominant player at this point.





Back to top
Larry Hollins
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2009
1545 posts

re: DL recruiting question


it takes time for guys to develop. this is the sec. look at brockers, he didn't develop until his jr. year along with logan. minter is in his 4th year and is having his best year. obj, landry, collins were all 5* players and none of them is dominating. you are asking too much for a soph. to dominate the sec.





Back to top
TheTruthPolice
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Aug 2010
305 posts

re: DL recruiting question


quote:

Seems most of our All-American types have made more noise in their first 2 years. Color me skeptical.


Who are you talking about lights it up in their first two years more than Johnson? It's Mingo's 4th year and he has the same amount of tackles, HALF the amount of tfl, and one more sack than Johnson. Mingo and Montgomery did not set the world on fire until their 3rd year. Same with Logan and Brockers. Nevis and even Dorsey were not great until they were seniors. Even going back to Spears and Hill the 3rd year is when they put it together. Here is a 2nd year Dorsey and Johnson stats and remember Johnson has 4 games left.

GP-GS Solo Ast Total TFL-Yds Sack-Yds
Glenn Dorsey 13-1 16 12 28 4.0 - 24 3.0-23
A. Johnson 9-3 10 15 25 8.0- 24 2.0 -13






Back to top
TigerfFaithful
New Orleans
Member since Oct 2007
300 posts

re: DL recruiting question


The reasons for lack of depth in the middle next season are circumstances involving the 2009 and 2010 classes:

2009:
Brockers - great player, but declared for NFL as a RS soph

Downs - graduating; arguably should have redshirted as a true freshman

Davenport - moved to OL

Logan - great player, but could declare for NFL after this season

Also note that although his eligibility would have expired last season, 2009 recruit Hicks was dismissed from the team before ever playing a down.

2010:
Copeland - recruited for DL but moved to FB.

Ego - only DT from 2010 class

If Logan leaves early, Ego would be the only DT on the team next season from those two classes.






Back to top
billyholawboy
Southern Miss Fan
Denham Springs
Member since Dec 2007
307 posts

re: DL recruiting question


I'm not sure there arent a few juco DT's out there that wouldn't come in next year & push Ego as the 2nd best DT from day 1 (assuming Logan leaves, of course).

Plus, the way we rotate DT's, you could argue of you are in the top 4, you're practically a starter.






Back to top
deuce985
LSU Fan
Member since Feb 2008
13274 posts

re: DL recruiting question


I'm willing to bet LSU is comfortable with Mickey and Thomas at DT because it doesn't seem like they've had much urgency at that position recruiting. They know they can get who they want at the position too...

They must be comfortable with Ego, Johnson, Freak, and Thomas.






Back to top
TheTruthPolice
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Aug 2010
305 posts

re: DL recruiting question


quote:

I'm not sure there arent a few juco DT's out there that wouldn't come in next year & push Ego as the 2nd best DT from day 1 (assuming Logan leaves, of course).


Yes there is one that has a small chance of doing that this year in Toby Johnson. We are not on his radar. There is still a better chance of even him not making the two deep than beating out Ego. Look at the top 4 d-lineman last year in Autry, McCullers, Sentimore, and Damien Jacobs. All are very bad or below average SEC players. If this was a year like 2011 with three sure thing players we would be after one, but this year is like last year.






Back to top
sunnydaze
New Orleans Saints Fan
over the hills
Member since Jan 2010
14770 posts

re: DL recruiting question


quote:

JOhnson is not the player he was hyped to be;he isn't bad, but he is not a dominant player at this point


he was the best DL on the team the first few weeks until les benched him in favor of his pet downs.

not sure what games you were watching






Back to top
Larry Hollins
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2009
1545 posts

re: DL recruiting question


you mean miles makes decisions about defensive players.





Back to top
sunnydaze
New Orleans Saints Fan
over the hills
Member since Jan 2010
14770 posts

re: DL recruiting question


Ask Danny McCray and Karnell Hatcher


This post was edited on 11/6 at 4:33 pm


Back to top
Vito Andolini
Member since Sep 2009
373 posts

re: DL recruiting question


quote:

Ask Danny McCray and Karnell Hatcher


FYI, Danny McCray started for the Cowbobys on Sunday.






Back to top
TheTruthPolice
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Aug 2010
305 posts

re: DL recruiting question


quote:

JOhnson is not the player he was hyped to be;he isn't bad, but he is not a dominant player at this point.


I just don't get this at all. He is in 2nd year out of high school. There has not been a more dominant D lineman at LSU that was just in his 2nd year at LSU. He has 8 tfl already and is on pace for 11-12 tfl for the year. Spears and Hill 2nd year 8tfl combined when they were on the field 90% of the time. Glen Dorsey and Tyson Jackson in their second year removed from high-school had just 5 tfl combined ...They were the two highest DL taken in the nfl draft in our history, both top five picks. Where do you people get this stuff from? Please find any DL in Saban/Miles era that is putting up the numbers Freak is in his second year removed from high school? The only one that comes even close is Kyle Williams in 03, and he had a lot more snaps that year.






Back to top


Back to top




//