neither one of them did enough in their time with the magic to really justify retiring the number
Both had multiple all-star appearances, an nba finals appearance and are clearly the two biggest stars the team has had.
Shaq did more than Dwight did for that franchise.
No way. Shaq is obviously the better player, but Shaq only had 3 playoff appearances and left the team high and dry in free agency. Dwight had 5 playoff appearances and even though he missed the last quarter of the 11-12 season, no way do the Magic make the playoffs without Dwight that year.