Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there - Page 3 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
tgrbaitn08
USA Fan
Member since Dec 2007
37960 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

The error (and I think it was a major error) was in the use of the timeout


Yeah that's my biggest beef. If you know you're gonna kick the fg, which I have no problem with that call, then just do it. Don't frick around and play silly games. They know what you're doing. Just take the 3 points and save your TO.






Back to top
Brettesaurus Rex
New Orleans Saints Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2009
22810 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

And finally, has that Super Bowl conversion play to Moore ever NOT worked when you needed 2 yards or a touchdown?

In theory? Absolutely. But this is the exact kind of thinking will lose you a game if you stick to that regardless of the situation. But don't you think the Falcons would have keyed on that considering that's pretty much a go to play of ours? The risk of it not working out was exponentially more harmful than the potential of you to be able to ice the game.

You can't be wreckless in situations like that against a good offense, because they will make you pay. Just look at what we have done to teams in the past the same exact way.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Brettesaurus Rex
New Orleans Saints Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2009
22810 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

Yeah that's my biggest beef. If you know you're gonna kick the fg, which I have no problem with that call, then just do it. Don't frick around and play silly games. They know what you're doing. Just take the 3 points and save your TO.

I wouldn't be as mad about that considering now close they were to catching Bierman offsides. That's a cheap way and almost no risk involved shot to ice the game. If it doesn't work, oh well you get one less TO. If it does, you win.






Back to top
tgrbaitn08
USA Fan
Member since Dec 2007
37960 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


I agree but it's just risky with time to TO ratio. Imagine if we would have had to drive 80 yards if ATL would have scored. 2 time outs with 45 seconds would have been a hell of a lot better than 80 yards in 45 seconds with only 1 time out.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Tiger in Texas
Southeastern LA Fan
Houston, Texas
Member since Sep 2004
12713 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


I like gutsy calls, but no, not in that situation, force Atlanta to come back with a TD. If we missed it, all too easy for Falcons to bring it into OT with a FG , which we don't want on the first game of the season.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
CM84
USA Fan
Louisiana
Member since Nov 2007
2493 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

Down by 3, the worst you get is OT. They don't even try for the TD.


Fail






Back to top
lsutigers1992
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2006
10751 posts
 Online 

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


Bull shite. They get to the 30, they go safe. They're not going to risk an INT.

The NFL is a pansy-ass "play the percentages" league.



This post was edited on 9/8 at 10:09 pm


Back to top
jpggpj
New Orleans Saints Fan
Chair
Member since Oct 2005
2791 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


The Saints O line had their head up their asses. If they were lining up to strictly draw the Falcons offsides, when the Falcons jumped SOMEBODY on the Saints right side of the line should have jumped too and would have easily gotten the neutral zone infraction call.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
alajones
LSU Fan
Hell
Member since Oct 2005
22078 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


I agree with Rex.


4 yards away from ending the game. If you miss, they still have 96 yards to go.

Les was in a similar situation vs Bama last year. He couldn't make the gutsy call either.






Back to top
Bayou
LSU Fan
Arizona Desert
Member since Feb 2005
24206 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

4 yards away from ending the game. If you miss, they still have 96 yards to go.

3.5 minutes for an Offense like that is a lot of time to manage kicking three to tie and go into OT. We are very lucky they didn't score a TD. Kicking the 3 was the correct call.






Back to top
Rex
LSU Fan
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
55038 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


You make as much sense here as you do on the Political Talk board: NONE.

You're arguing against yourself when you say "An offense like that" and "We are very lucky they didn't score a TD".






Back to top
  Replies (0)
VOR
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
New Orleans
Member since Apr 2009
41198 posts
 Online 

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

Take the points and force a touch down.


Was the right call. When they come up to the line they were looking for a specific defensive lineup and didn't see it. Hence, the timeout and the field goal. Good call.






Back to top
Rex
LSU Fan
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
55038 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

Was the right call.

No, it wasn't. And if Steven Jackson had caught the ball he should have caught you'd see why.

There are arguments pro and con, to be sure, each with RISKS... but going for it had a potential REWARD, i.e. an automatic win for gaining one yard, that outweighed the risk. Even upon a failure to gain that one yard Atlanta still would have had a lot of work to do.






Back to top
corndeaux
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Member since Sep 2009
5362 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


4th down play is the wrong one to look at. They shouldn't have run Ingram on 1st. THAT was a wasted down





Back to top
  Replies (0)
VOR
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
New Orleans
Member since Apr 2009
41198 posts
 Online 

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


23 - 17







Back to top
  Replies (0)
TigerWise
USA Fan
Riverboat Hallelujah
Member since Sep 2010
20638 posts
 Online 

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

Hence, the timeout and the field goal. Good call.


Should have taken a delay of game instead of calling timeout.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
EarthwormJim
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2005
9766 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

There are arguments pro and con, to be sure, each with RISKS... but going for it had a potential REWARD


Kicking the field goal had a REWARD, i.e. and automatic 3 points and forcing a team(one held to 7 points for 45 minutes) to score a TD in the final minute.

quote:

No, it wasn't. And if Steven Jackson had caught the ball he should have caught you'd see why.


And if we don't make it on 4th, Atlanta still sends to overtime with the Jackson drop.

quote:

Even upon a failure to gain that one yard Atlanta still would have had a lot of work to do


Not really, they would have to go fewer yards in the same amount of time to tie the game with a failed conversion.






Back to top
XanderCrews
LSU Fan
Member since Mar 2009
297 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


Second guessing a game is natural because you think you know something about football because you have watched it most of your adult life.

The reality is you dont know shitake. If you did you would be on the sidelines.

That being said talking about it is fun and stimulates thought and conversations.


Just FYI you have to take the points in that scenario.






Back to top
lsutigers1992
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Mar 2006
10751 posts
 Online 

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


quote:

The reality is you dont know shitake. If you did you would be on the sidelines.



Thank you, Jim Mora. That was definitely the Jim Mora Decision.

By the way, what do Jim Mora and I have in common?
Neither of us has won a playoff game in the NFL.






Back to top
Fox Mulder
Tulane Fan
Austin, TX
Member since Dec 2010
24830 posts

re: Sorry, but Payton should have gone for the first down there


This is the worst thread in ST recent memory.

Payton made the call and it was proven on the field to be the right call. Are we playing "what if" after beating a good team and holding a very lethal offense to 17 points

Breesus






Back to top


Back to top