Started By
Message
locked post

Was there any talk about why 3 SCOTUS skipped speech?

Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:53 pm
Posted by SirWinston
PNW
Member since Jul 2014
81346 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:53 pm
I'm stunned this wasn't a bigger story - is there precedent for SCOTUS skipping a newly elected POTUS' first joint session?

My best guess is that RGB skipped bc she's a partisan count and then Thomas and Alito skipped so that she'd have cover and it wouldn't be viewed as a partisan issue so much.
Posted by Seldom Seen
Member since Feb 2016
39990 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:54 pm to
They had a meeting with the Russians.
Posted by jamboybarry
Member since Feb 2011
32642 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:54 pm to
The WaPo live feed said that's a normal occurrence. Take that for what it's worth
Posted by Iowa Golfer
Heaven
Member since Dec 2013
10229 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:55 pm to
A couple never have gone. I forget which ones. I think RBG was the only noticeable absence.
Posted by KCT
Psalm 23:5
Member since Feb 2010
38911 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:56 pm to
RBG decided to stay home and read the Constitution for the first time.
This post was edited on 3/2/17 at 9:56 pm
Posted by SirWinston
PNW
Member since Jul 2014
81346 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:56 pm to
Interesting - strange that they would skip such a big event tho.
Posted by BigEdLSU
All around the south
Member since Sep 2010
20268 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:56 pm to
What stops dems from doing makeup like movie quality to someone else and rbg be dead
Posted by Bench McElroy
Member since Nov 2009
33922 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:56 pm to
Clarence Thomas: “I don’t go because it has become so partisan and it’s very uncomfortable for a judge to sit there. There’s a lot that you don’t hear on TV — the catcalls, the whooping and hollering and under-the-breath comments.”

Samuel Alito: “It’s very strange to go as a justice. We sit there like potted plants. People who watch on television have no idea what’s really happening on the floor. There’s a lot of back and forth between the Democrats and the Republicans. They keep up a running commentary on what the president is saying. Some of it is pretty sharp. None of that is ever picked up because it’s Congress’s home turf. There are boom mikes around, so I think they could probably pick up these comments if they wanted to, but I guess that’s off limits.

“We sit there and the president will say something and members of the president’s party will stand up and start applauding. Members of the other party often will not. But every once in a while the president will say something that is nonpartisan. ‘The United States is a great country.’ ‘We support our men and women in uniform.’ Then everyone’s applauding and standing. We look foolish sitting there, so we stand up and start to applaud. And then we’ll get faked out. The president will get say, ‘This is a great country’—and everyone will stand up and start to applaud—‘because we’re gonna do this, we’re gonna enact this legislation.’ It’s a very odd experience.”
This post was edited on 3/2/17 at 10:00 pm
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
76504 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:56 pm to
quote:

My best guess is that RGB skipped


Who?
Posted by golfntiger32
Ohio
Member since Oct 2013
12486 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:58 pm to
quote:


RBG decided to stay home and read the Constitution for the first time.


That is amazing since she was alive when it was written.
Posted by JDDawg
Member since May 2009
278 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:59 pm to
Ruth Gator Binsberg? Go Gator.
Posted by SpidermanTUba
my house
Member since May 2004
36128 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 9:59 pm to
past their bedtimes.
Posted by buckeye_vol
Member since Jul 2014
35236 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 10:05 pm to
quote:

and then Thomas and Alito skipped so that she'd have cover and it wouldn't be viewed as a partisan issue so much.
So you would rather write out that post, than take 2 second to Google it? 2015 Article
quote:

This year, six justices were in attendance, while three of the most conservative members of the court, Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, were noticeably absent. In the modern era, custom has held that the justices would show up in their official robes and sit impassively. But in recent years, they've become more resistant to the tradition.
Do you ever question your exteme inferences, when you realize the truth was very easy to find and quite different than your inferences?
Posted by Iowa Golfer
Heaven
Member since Dec 2013
10229 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 10:05 pm to
Well, speaking to RBG only, she's probably not in good health, and she did get political during the campaign, so I don't blame her.

Speaking of not looking like they are in good health, without getting morbid, one of the attendees didn't look like a magazine cover for Women's Health.

That's what I noticed. But I'm a funny guy. I notice stuff like SCOTUS Justices that look like they could die in the next five minutes.
Posted by UHTiger
Member since Jan 2007
5231 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 10:13 pm to
Wow. In America, Brit boy, this is how it usually happens.

Must be different in parliament
Posted by airfernando
Member since Oct 2015
15248 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 10:21 pm to
I think they should skip these speeches anyway. They also shouldn't be socializing or hobnobbing in my opinion. Of course, they should be honest and objective but aren't.
Posted by OysterPoBoy
City of St. George
Member since Jul 2013
34990 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 11:28 pm to
Designated Survivor
Posted by larry289
Holiday Island, AR
Member since Nov 2009
3858 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 11:46 pm to
There wasn't enough room upfront for RBG's roller bed and drip.
Posted by Sentrius
Fort Rozz
Member since Jun 2011
64757 posts
Posted on 3/2/17 at 11:52 pm to
The president isn't the only one that has a designated survivor.

Congress and SCOTUS all have designated survivors for joint addresses and SOTUs.

For the supreme court, 3 is needed for cases to be ruled on and decided. Only 5 justices are allowed to attend the speech.

For Congress, at least x amount of representatives and senators need to be surviving as well. I don't think that number has been disclosed.

Continuity of government is a big deal and is codified into constitutional amendment and statuary legislation. We have to make sure there is no crisis of leadership and vacuum of power if the worst does happen.
Posted by buckeye_vol
Member since Jul 2014
35236 posts
Posted on 3/3/17 at 12:02 am to
quote:

For the supreme court, 3 is needed for cases to be ruled on and decided. Only 5 justices are allowed to attend the speech.
Since when? Scalia stopped attending for 20 years, but until recently, most justices attended the event.

I guess there could be a policy that is not explicitly stated or at least accessible to us, but it also seems like something mistakenly accepted from some fictional work.

I mean why would they openly list the presidential designated survivor, but not the SCOTUS, if it existed? Designated Survivor List

In addition, why would the SCOTUS need one when their are federal judges who could succeed them, especially since the designated survivor has often been 15+ down the list?
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram