How moderate are "Moderate Muslims", really?

"moderate Muslims" buy the bombs instead of wearing them

quote:

---

but I can't, because I'm not comfortable with that answer.

---

Trust your gut it knows lies when it hears them

quote:

---

But are moderate Muslims really like mainstream Americans? Do moderate Muslims support equality for women? Do they support LBGT rights? Are they supportive of our Constitution and laws?

---

Most american muslims are like americans. Now the rest of the world? they probably aren't like americans as they are in much poorer countries.

I used to work with quite a few muslims. And the only thing you would notice is that they didn't drink or eat pork. Other than that, they were just like everyone at my work. And hell many ate pork and drank.

just like with christianity, most muslims aren't hard core true believers. they believe but other thigns are way more important.

quote:

---

I know "muslims" who are just as American as anyone else.

---

But I suspect that these types of Muslims are not the majority, or even close to being a majority. That's why they are leaving, right?

Having said that, even if they are "just as American as anyone else", that means they send their kids to school, watch LSU football, etc... What are their politics? Do they want to make homosexuality illegal? Do they support equal rights for women?

I knew a couple from Pakistan that lived in my neighborhood. They came around to the block parties, he was a Jags fan, he drank beers with us, his kids played with my kids and they would all hang out at the pool together. I remember it being a big deal in the neighborhood because their daughter was very upset because she was turning 12 and she was no longer going to be allowed to swim in the neighborhood pool because per their laws and customs, she couldn't show her arms and legs in public. They were also starting to get worried about finding an acceptable husband for their daughter. He took a job elsewhere, and they moved away, so I don't really know how that ended.

Radical Muslims want to kill you.

Moderate Muslims want radical Muslims to kill you for them.

The moderates won't come to kill you.

But once the Muslim community becomes the majority, they expect you to behave in line with their sensibilities and if you don't, they won't lift a finger to help you when the radicals come for you.

I'll try to answer your questions, but you've asked like twenty in a small space, and each requires a very complicated answer if I were to be thorough.

quote:

---

We know we have a problem with radical jihadists around the world who are trying to create mayhem and destruction. I have seen debates over how the vast majority of Muslims are "moderate", and we have nothing to worry about the followers of Islam, as a whole because of this.

---

Well this is by and large true. Islamism is the problem, specifically Salafi/Wahabis, who come from the most extreme school of Islamic jurisprudence. This group in particular is the belief of the major terrorist groups. Beyond that there is as wide variety of belief in the Islamic world as there is in the West.

quote:

---

Or is the difference between the majority of so-called moderates and their radical brethren much more subtle?

---

The lines are clearly delineated along sectarian lines, but sometimes there is a national aspect, or an ethnic one. A Turk, for example, isn't likely to believe in the Pan-Arabic aspects of the Islamists. The difference also depends on wealth and class. So the question is complicated.

By and large I'd argue that most Muslims (not in the West) are indifferent to the West, instead concerned with the material facts of their life, which is what I'd argue is also the mien of the vast majority of people in the West.

There is a streak of liberalism appearing in the Islamic world, but many of the people who could lead it are chased out or killed by authoritarian governments (which we generally support), which is actually a pattern that has been consistent in the post-War era.

Also for the most part, moderate Muslims cannot do anything about the Salafis, because the Islamists are small, organized, and are extremely good at propaganda. What drives moderation, in general? Mostly capitalism and wealth, but the model in the Islamic world has either been to use the oil wealth to sustain massive welfare states or to ensure wealth goes into the hands of very few, situations which either drive ennui and disillusionment, or continue to alienate the underclasses, who become ripe for Islamism due to that alienation.

This is a extremely general answer, but the questions you posed are book length in scope, and aren't easily answerable without a lot of context, both historical and contemporary.

quote:

---

Muslim's in France are a minority as well. They aren't above 10% in the latest projections.

---

But aren't there towns or enclaves where they are the majority? Aren't these the so-called, "NO-GO" zones?

quote:

---

They'll rape your wife & daughters.....then kill them.....but won't mutilate their vaginas.

---

I don't know about this, but they'll surely stand by quietly while others who practice their faith do in the name of Islam.