re: The official Interstellar thread (spoilers)

Yeah, really. You just don't have the mental acumen. If Cooper adjusts prior events from a now non-existent time line due the adjustment, it makes perfect sense.

Do you even science fiction bro?

If T=time sequence and X=actions of charcters Y=actions of The Others Z=outcome

T(alpha)+X(alpha)+Y(alpha)=Z(alpha)


Interstellar has some things going for that Terminator does not. I do not think you can fix the fact that John Connor's dad is from the future but was sent by him to save himself from the "Terminator."

Now your problem with Interstellar is that Cooper's future self sends his past self a message that causes him to go on a mission that would have never happened in the first place. I get that.

Think Murphey's Law.

Whatever can happen will happen.

Cooper went on his first mission while on a different timeline. His future self changed the timeline in the terresac. In the terresac Cooper has access to every point in time in Murphey's bedroom. He choose to go back to a point earlier that his first mission and send the coordinates for NASA in order to create a new time line. The adjusted sequence seems to create a paradox but it is not due to an alternate timeline that made the movie possible in the first place. The clue is the emphasis on Murphey's Law.

quote:

---

The clue is the

---

Dammit

quote:

---

I do not think you can fix the fact that John Connor's dad is from the future but was sent by him to save himself from the "Terminator."

---

Sure you can. They become 5th dimensional after the defeat of the machines.

quote:

---

Think Murphey's Law.

Whatever can happen will happen.

---

Yeah, there's a problem with that. Well, more than 1 actually. Especially since Murphy's adage is about failure.

quote:

---

His future self changed the timeline in the terresac. In the terresac Cooper has access to every point in time in Murphey's bedroom.

---

He can never get to the tesseract. Oh, and the tesseract was never built.

quote:

---

The clue is the emphasis on Murphey's Law.

---

Write more on this.

Murphey's Law is defined as not whatever can go wrong will go wrong but as whatever can happen will happen. Oh, that is kind if a big deal you should have caught because Murphey specificly asked Cooper why they named her after something bad.

You are stuck on a linear timeline. The terresac was built in the future on a different timeline because Cooper communicated through it. The Others opened the wormhole 50 years prior to the beginning of the movie. We do not know for sure what happened in the alternative future where Cooper communicates with Murphey to begin with because it is never realized due to Cooper entering the Terresac and going further back to change the timeline so mankind on earth could survive.

So a bootstrap paradox eliminates the illogical. The logical conclusion is that Cooper at a later point goes on a mission and has to go into the blackhole probably in a similar way as the movie but he was approached by NASA later than the movies timeline. The problem is that it is too late for humanity. Murphey would have been older and may not be in the right frame of mind to be of assistance. Cooper enters the terresac and goes to the point in the original timeline where he can reach Murph because she is necessary for the survival of mankind on earth and abroad. In the movie's timeline Cooper realizes they didn't choose him but Murphey. Murphey Law suggests that what ever can happen will happen. Because the terresac gave Cooper access to alter the course of history, he did. Why? Because mankind was born on Earth but was not meant to die there. Murphey's Law sees to it that it does not.

So the fact that he Bran talked about the fact that Murphey's Law had an impact on whether life developed in a system that was near Gargantuan makes it scientific baw. Because a system was so close to a black hole it made life impossible. Why? Murphey's Law. Not enough things could happen to make life possible. BTW, you think I give two shites how to spell Murphey's Law or that whether I do makes a damn bit of difference? Factoid, you lack the mentality to conceptualize a non-linear timeline. Sucks to be you.

The movie defines Murphey's Law. Cooper and Murphey talk about her being named after the law. She asks him why he named her after it? He said Murphey's Law doesn't mean if it can go wrong it will, he said it means whatever can happen will happen and he said that sounded okay to him. Also Cooper and Bran talked about the fact that the water planet didn't have life because it was so close to black hole and with Murphey's Law not enough things could happen to create life. Jesus, it is like you guys didn't even watch this movie. Go watch the movie again and get back to me.

quote:

---

So the fact that he Bran talked about the fact that Murphey's Law had an impact on whether life developed in a system that was near Gargantuan makes it scientific baw.

---

Wow

quote:

---

Because a system was so close to a black hole it made life impossible. Why? Murphey's Law. Not enough things could happen to make life possible.

---

Whiskey?

quote:

---

Factoid, you lack the mentality to conceptualize a non-linear timeline. Sucks to be you.

---

You are so confused.

If you take the movies premise it was communicating with us. Cooper uses gravity to reach Murphey and invariably himself. You cannot assume they didn't do more to steer us in the right direction. We just are not privileged to those commications.