Name a Theoretical Pitching Staff with your Favorite Team's All-Time Greats

Can i move starters into my pen? Cause if so

Clayton Kershaw
Sandy Koufax
Don Drysdale
Don Sutton
Don Newcombe

Orel Herschiser
Fernando Valenzuela

Eric Gagne (steroid version)

quote:

---

Can i move my starters into my pen?

---

I'd be mad if you didn't!

quote:

---

After Clayton wins the cy young this year, that staff will have 11 with everyone having one

---

Well now you're just getting cocky

Greg Maddux
Tom Glavine
John Smoltz
Phil Neikro
Warren Spahn

Setup Craig Kimbrel
Closer John Rocker

Steve Carlton
Robin Roberts
Curt Shilling
Roy Halladay
Cliff Lee


Brad Lidge
Jose Mesa
Mitch Williams

Jose Rijio & Johnny Cueto are pretty much the only 2 post WWII starting pitchers that would be on the list. Maybe you could make a case for Mario Soto.

The Reds would rely on the lineup & the bullpen



Randy Myers
John Franco
Aroldis Chapman
Danny Graves
Rob Dibble
Norm Charlton
Jeff Brantley

No Seaver?

But mine is a 4 starter for playoffs

Dizzy Dean
Bob Gibson
Steve Carlton
Cy Young

Middle
Carpenter
Wainwright
Bob Forsch
Silver King
Three Finger Brown

Set Up
Lee Smith

Closer
Bruce Sutter

Kershaw
Koufax
Hershiser
Nomo
Fernando
Sutton

Brian wilson

Rangers (remember we don't have much in terms of pitching):

Starters:
Nolan Ryan
Gaylord Perry
Charlie Hough
Yu Darvish (pre-injury causing Japanese Fade version)
Ferguson Jenkins (1974 version, still holds club record for most wins in a season)

Bullpen:
Jim Kern
Sparky Lyle
Alexi Ogando (7th inning version, not starter version that can't stay healthy)
Joe Nathan
Neftali Feliz (2010 ROY version, not the current version that can only throw one pitch, and not that well)

Gibson since he was best athlete in 60's and won't burn bench