what to do with a little retirement acct | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
oldcharlie8
LA-Lafayette Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2012
3534 posts

what to do with a little retirement acct


have 27k in an old acct. with the state. they claim that, if i leave it in there til i'm 60, i will collect 700.00/month for the rest of my life. should i roll it into an IRA or wait 25 more years to collect the 700.00?

wwyd?



This post was edited on 7/10 at 1:33 pm



Back to top
Share:
Janky
LSU Fan
Team Primo
Member since Jun 2011
7029 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct



IRA






Back to top
oldcharlie8
LA-Lafayette Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2012
3534 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


that's what i was thinking. thanks.







Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55408 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


Wait, $700 per month or per year?





Back to top
Volvagia
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Mar 2006
40220 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


I would assume per month....

He can probably already pull 700 per year from it for the rest of his life






Back to top
oldcharlie8
LA-Lafayette Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2012
3534 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


quote:

$700 per month






Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55408 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


That's 8400 per year. You need to evaluate how well you think you can get the IRA to perform.





Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55408 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


If he invests no more money, at a conservative 5% rate, that money grows to roughly $92,000 over 25 years. At a withdrawal rate of 5%, he gets $4600 per year. Far less than he would get keeping it there.





Back to top
Janky
LSU Fan
Team Primo
Member since Jun 2011
7029 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


If he earned 8.5% (Dave Ramsey says 10% in a good growth stock mutual fund ), then $8400 would represent about a 4% distribution. I personally would rather take my chances myself as opposed leaving it with the state.


This post was edited on 7/10 at 2:11 pm


Back to top
kennypowers816
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Jan 2010
1665 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


quote:

That's 8400 per year. You need to evaluate how well you think you can get the IRA to perform.


I agree with this. The other question is how old are you? If you're 59, you're probably not going to outperform what the state is offering. If you're 21, you could definitely outperform it.

Just a thought.

ETA: Oops...
quote:

or wait 25 more years


I don't know... I'd probably consider leaving it with the state. I would completely understand someone not having confidence in the long term sustainability of that program, but I personally wouldn't be overly concerned. I wouldn't mind a little peace of mind knowing that no matter what happens to my individual IRA, I have a fairly sure thing in a $700/month pension.



This post was edited on 7/10 at 2:23 pm


Back to top
Broke
LSU Fan
AKA Buttercup
Member since Sep 2006
55408 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


quote:

If he earned 8.5% (Dave Ramsey says 10% in a good growth stock mutual fund ), then $8400 would represent about a 4% distribution. I personally would rather take my chances myself as opposed leaving it with the state.


There are pluses and minuses with each side. It's not a slam dunk either way. So whatever he wants to do would be ok imo.






Back to top
Bubba Bexley
LSU Fan
Member since May 2007
3579 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


My wife was recently in a similar situation (in Mississippi). I was leaning toward pulling it out, but she wanted to leave it in. By leaving it in, if she goes back to the state she already has those years banked as far as credited service, plus the time for being fully vested has increased from when she started from 4 years to 8 years now. If you take it out and go back to the state, you have the option of paying the money back and getting your service years back. At least that's how I think it works. Reading through all the crap gave me a headache and I had too much going on at the time to really figure it out, so I eventually said to heck with it.





Back to top
Vols&Shaft83
Tennessee Fan
Member since Dec 2012
11349 posts
 Online 

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


quote:

If he earned 8.5% (Dave Ramsey says 10% in a good growth stock mutual fund ), then $8400 would represent about a 4% distribution. I personally would rather take my chances myself as opposed leaving it with the state.


Actually dave says 12% which is doable over a 25 year period, although I wouldn't count on it. But like you I'd rather take my chances at beating 8.5% than take my chances leaving it with the state, who is well-known for its ability to manage money and keep promises






Back to top
Volvagia
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Mar 2006
40220 posts

re: what to do with a little retirement acct


quote:

If he invests no more money, at a conservative 5% rate, that money grows to roughly $92,000 over 25 years. At a withdrawal rate of 5%, he gets $4600 per year. Far less than he would get keeping it there.


Not really a fair comparison though.

Why would you assume that he would only withdraw the growth?

I know that's the conventional rate, but the state plan sure as hell is dipping into that principal and gambling that he won't live to withdraw for much more than 20 years, letting them keep what's left.

Also, in your hypothetical one would still have 92000 in an account that could be passed on, whereas in the state account you'll have nothing.

These are very important additional points to consider...



This post was edited on 7/10 at 4:03 pm


Back to top


Back to top




//