Bourbon help | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
jflsufan
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Mar 2013
253 posts

Bourbon help



Should I trade 1 bottle of Pappy Van Winkle 15 year old for 2 bottles of Eagle Rare 17 from the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection?






Back to top
Share:
GaryMyMan
USA Fan
Lower Garden District
Member since May 2007
10887 posts

re: Bourbon help


No no no no no.

On taste alone, no. On value, no.

I would trade it for a bottle of George T Stagg and William Larue Weller. But not two bottles of Eagle Rare 17.

You should sell it to me, though.




This post was edited on 4/6 at 6:14 pm


Back to top
Dandy Lion
Georgia Fan
Regnum Asturorum
Member since Feb 2010
31489 posts

re: Bourbon help


Had a conversation today with an ´expert ´who swears Pappy Van Winkle is one of the fledgling century´s greatest hoodwinkings.

I´ve got no dog in the fight, and could care less, but I thought it important to mention (as we were talking about wine, and he brought it up).






Back to top
GaryMyMan
USA Fan
Lower Garden District
Member since May 2007
10887 posts

re: Bourbon help


I respectfully disagree. I've had the 20 and 23 year Pappy and I've had the 12 year Family Reserve and their Rye. The one thing they had in common was they all made me grin like an idiot, and very few bourbons are capable of that. The only ones who have come close to that same feeling of "Eureka!" are the 4 Roses Small Batch Limited 2012, the George T. Stagg, and the Elijah Craig 18. Taste is subjective, but for me Pappy is worth the chase and the price.


This post was edited on 4/6 at 7:25 pm


Back to top
TheDude
LSU Fan
Member since May 2004
1607 posts

re: Bourbon help


I'm gonna have to disagree. I would make that trade. I've had both and I'd rather have one bottle of eagle rare 17 than a bottle of pappy 15. I agree George T Stagg is good but I found the heat to be a bit much. I drink Bookers fairly often and don't find it as hot. Also, I really didn't care for Elijah Craig 18. Not worth the price at all. As you said though, taste is subjective.


This post was edited on 4/6 at 11:46 pm


Back to top
  Replies (0)
Zappas Stache
Snotterburgh
Member since Apr 2009
10497 posts
 Online 

re: Bourbon help


quote:

I respectfully disagree. I've had the 20 and 23 year Pappy and I've had the 12 year Family Reserve and their Rye. The one thing they had in common was they all made me grin like an idiot, and very few bourbons are capable of that. The only ones who have come close to that same feeling of "Eureka!" are the 4 Roses Small Batch Limited 2012,


All good but I prefer the pappy Rye over the other pappy's and it is less hyped and more affordable. The 4 roses small batch was too spicy for my tastes but I hear it grows on you.






Back to top
jose canseco
LSU Fan
Houston via Houma via BR via NOLA
Member since Jul 2007
4359 posts

re: Bourbon help


I have heard the same thing at several different places.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
gmrkr5
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Jul 2009
9582 posts

re: Bourbon help


quote:

The 4 roses small batch was too spicy for my tastes but I hear it grows on you.


I usually love the Single Barrel but the last bottle I picked up was too spicy.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
FredSecunda
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since May 2005
7158 posts

re: Bourbon help


Good looking finding the Pappy rye. It's my white whale.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
jflsufan
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Mar 2013
253 posts

re: Bourbon help


I turned it down. Now the guy is offering me either an Eagle Rare 17 + Stagg or Eagle Rare 17 + Jefferson's Presidential Select 18 for my Pappy 15.





Back to top
Neauxla
New Orleans Saints Fan
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2008
29900 posts

re: Bourbon help


Can anyone link me to that several page thread on Bourbon from a couple weeks ago? I can't find it.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
gmrkr5
LSU Fan
BR
Member since Jul 2009
9582 posts

re: Bourbon help


quote:

Eagle Rare 17 + Jefferson's Presidential Select 18


i'd take that






Back to top
  Replies (0)
GaryMyMan
USA Fan
Lower Garden District
Member since May 2007
10887 posts

re: Bourbon help


quote:

Now the guy is offering me either an Eagle Rare 17 + Stagg or Eagle Rare 17 + Jefferson's Presidential Select 18 for my Pappy 15.


Either one of those are solid offers. I prefer the Stagg to the JPS18. But like I said: I'm not wild about the ER17.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Dr Beardface
New Orleans Saints Fan
Here and There
Member since Jan 2008
3018 posts

re: Bourbon help


Get him to make it Stagg + JPS 18 and call it a day.





Back to top
jflsufan
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Mar 2013
253 posts

re: Bourbon help


Yeah but I've already got 2 JPS 18's in the bunker. I think I would do Stagg and William Larue Weller for the 15. I still have an unopened 20 on the shelf. Went through one bottle of it at Christmas. The problem is I've never tried the 15. Make's it hard to part ways with it.





Back to top
drockw1
LSU Fan
a sand wedge from The Kingpin
Member since Jun 2006
2563 posts

re: Bourbon help


Don't get me wrong, the 15 is an exquisite bourbon...as said above, it passes the "grinning like a fool" test...

I did a flight of PVW 15, VW 12, and the VW Reserve Rye, and the rye caught my attention more than the 15. Not to say that will be the case for everyone, it's all preference, but it wasn't even close which one I preferred.

I actually thought the 15 I had back in the fall of 2011 was a little better than the 2012 release. Can't put my finger on why...

If you really want to try the 15, wait til the fall and overpay for a glass at any of the bars that have the fortune of getting a bottle.

Demand has skyrocketed so much, it's sometimes easy to overvalue limited commodities like these...

Keep your JPS, and maybe try to do Stagg/WLW plus cash before parting with anything else...






Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top