La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013. | Page 3 | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
BeeFense5
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Kenner
Member since Jul 2010
18679 posts
 Online 

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

So roscoe mike, can I ask you......what do you feel about LSU going OOS and plucking top prospects from other states? Should LSU send them packing?


That's different!!!!!1111

We never get anyone to ever answer that question. Louisiana high school kids apparently are the only ones that aren't supposed to leave the state.






Back to top
roscoe mike
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Nov 2009
915 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


All right then. If this thread is undermining LSU, someone RA and have it removed.

I guess it doesn't really matter how many 4 & 5 star players from La. go to Alabama.






Back to top
H-Town Tiger
Toledo Fan
Member since Nov 2003
42629 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


Imagine of the OP was a Tennessee fan, wanna see OOS guys making an impact at Alabama? How about Jones and Hightower.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Prominentwon
McNeese State Fan
...that's where TOTS come from!
Member since Jan 2005
73490 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

All right then. If this thread is undermining LSU, someone RA and have it removed.

I guess it doesn't really matter how many 4 & 5 star players from La. go to Alabama.


I'll ask again.....


quote:

So roscoe mike, can I ask you......what do you feel about LSU going OOS and plucking top prospects from other states? Should LSU send them packing?






Back to top
roscoe mike
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Nov 2009
915 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


Dude, I'm well aware of our great prospects from out of state. That wasn't the point of this thread. I can start another one praising LSU's out of state recruiting prowess if you like.





Back to top
funnystuff
Member since Nov 2012
899 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


It matters how many good players go anywhere else. As far as we should be concerned, it's us vs. the field. If you want to make the argument that we are loosing that battle, I'd be interested in reading a more well thought out argument. But the argument you made here holds absolutely no validity.





Back to top
jrodLSUke
LSU Fan
Tigerdroppings Premium
Member since Jan 2011
6054 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

I guess it doesn't really matter how many 4 & 5 star players from La. go to Alabama.

I might not, actually. Take a look at your list and consider this:

If those LA recruits where taken off Bama's roster and placed on LSU's, do you really think that Saban and his team would not be winning championships?






Back to top
deathvalleyfreak43
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
4299 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


So you really just care about an 18 year old kids decision that much?





Back to top
  Replies (0)
roscoe mike
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Nov 2009
915 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


It wasn't an argument. It was factual info I posted. The interpretation of it is the argument. But no where did I say LSU recruits badly.





Back to top
BeeFense5
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Kenner
Member since Jul 2010
18679 posts
 Online 

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

Dude, I'm well aware of our great prospects from out of state. That wasn't the point of this thread. I can start another one praising LSU's out of state recruiting prowess if you like.


Then what's the point? All you are doing us pointing out that some players, a very small number, leave to play else where. You also only listed one real impact player. This cones across as an overly dramatic bitch about nothing.






Back to top
ECOTIGER
LSU Fan
westbank for life
Member since Dec 2007
1234 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


I would gladly take guys like this:

Brandon LaFell, Danny McCray, Kelvin Sheppard, Joseph Barksdale, Ron Brooks, Patrick Peterson, Terrance Toliver, Demetrius Byrd, Ryan Baker, Alex Hurst, Kevin Minter, Sam Montgomery, Michael Brockers, Craig Loston, Kadron Boone, JC Copeland Jalen Mills

than offering a guy just because he is from Louisiana.



This post was edited on 1/17 at 12:05 pm


Back to top
  Replies (0)
jrodLSUke
LSU Fan
Tigerdroppings Premium
Member since Jan 2011
6054 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

I can start another one praising LSU's out of state recruiting prowess if you like.

I would like to see that thread.

Let's see you put that together so this piece of crap can go away.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
ffishstik
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2007
2767 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


Alabma Players signed by LSU in the same time period:

2012 - Kwon Alexander
2011 - Stephen Rivers
2010 - Sam Gibson
2009 - Josh Williford
2008 - None
2007 - Phelon Jones and Sidell Corley

From a production standpoint, I would say that LSU has gotten at least as much production out of their signees from Alabama as Alabama has from it's Louisiana signees. Lacy was big for them this year, but there are LA kids on other teams in the SEC that have been highly productive as well.

Move on.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Smoke Green
Nebraska Fan
Tianjin, Peoples Republic of China
Member since Apr 2005
4172 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

Y'all are missing the point.



no they're not.


quote:

It's about locking down our state. Regardless of how many actually pan out,



you're just being silly now.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
roscoe mike
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Nov 2009
915 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

Then what's the point? All you are doing us pointing out that some players, a very small number, leave to play else where. You also only listed one real impact player. This cones across as an overly dramatic bitch about nothing.


Honestly, I never gave much thought to this until Tim Williams committed to Bama. When I looked up how many players overall, it seemed like a lot. Then when I checked and saw how many in prior years (1), it got my attention.

Obviously it was a mistake to bring it here.






Back to top
nicholastiger
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2004
6743 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


The only star in that group has been Lacy so far
Those other guys have been replaced by out of state players LSU recruited that have been just as good if not better.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
funnystuff
Member since Nov 2012
899 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

It wasn't an argument. It was factual info I posted. The interpretation of it is the argument. But no where did I say LSU recruits badly.


quote:

it remains a fact that La. players have made a significant contribution to Bama's championship run.
quote:

And here's what bothers me the most: in the six years prior Alabama recruiting classes (2001-2006), one La. player was signed.
quote:

This shite needs to stop
Sounds like an argument to me? More specifically, sounds very much like an argument that Miles isn't doing as well as he needs to. And since that is the argument that you don't want to admit you are making, I would like to point out that there would be much more effective ways of doing so. This attempt failed






Back to top
Prominentwon
McNeese State Fan
...that's where TOTS come from!
Member since Jan 2005
73490 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


OK, So who do you prefer in this list and who made a bigger impact?



2007
4* DE Luther Davis - Barksdale did about as much on the DL at LSU than Davis did at BAMA

2008
4* CB Robbie Green - Hatcher was better than Green. Also, Patrick Peterson was a joke at LSU. I compared Peterson to Hookfin.

2009
4* RB Eddie Lacy - The 1 guy that has mad an impact. He didn't learn to spell his name until his first semester on the BAMA campus.
4* WR Kenny Bell - LSU took Randle that year and Bell was scared to compete against him. Bell is mediocre at best. His only route is the go route and catches it if he's wide open. Otherwise, he's broken in half because he weights 130 lbs.
4* DT Darrington Sentimore

2010
None

2011
4* WR Bradley Sylve - Beckham, Landry or Sylve? Who do you prefer? Oh, Sylve got moved to DB. Want me to list the DB's?

2012
5* S Landon Collins - Corey Thompson got just as much playing time as Collins did his freshman year. Thompson will be a player at LSU.
4* MLB Denzel Duvall - Kwon Alexander anyone?

2013
4* DE Tim Williams - Sure, tell Herron to go to Tennessee. LSU doesn't need him.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Prominentwon
McNeese State Fan
...that's where TOTS come from!
Member since Jan 2005
73490 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


quote:

Obviously it was a mistake to bring it here.


It belongs on the Rant.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
wildtigercat93
LSU Fan
Hammond, LA
Member since Jul 2011
45066 posts

re: La. recruits signed by Bama from 2007-2013.


Words can not describe how stupid and obtuse you are being right now.





Back to top


Back to top