the show, is doing a great job of making it hard to know for sure who has Theon. There are strong hints that it is a Bolton, and is the Bastard. Hints since last season.
But the way things changed between mediums, no one knows for sure. He didn't seem to be in control during the torture. I read and I'm not sure that is Bolton's Bastard.
Both threads are more fun when discussing the show.
If you want to be a closet reader, then fine, just hold theories that are based on book speculation to yourself.
IMO, the two threads were better when it was show discussion and book discussion.
This reminds me of "Cartmanland" on South Park. If you have something and tell people they cannot come, they are going to want to see what it is about.
Many of us call out people for posting in this thread, only to later post in this thread.
(also, in May's defense. Looking at the casting gives away spoilers. )
This post was edited on 5/9 at 9:35 am