I think McDermott, McCollum, and Plumlee are on track to be first-team All-Americans for sure. The next 2 spots could be between Muhammad, McLemore, Burke, Russ Smith, and a couple other guys.
Only seen him play twice in my life so I can't say much. But his stat line doesn't seem incredible enough to get First-team honors as a guy playing at a tiny school. McDermott's does.