re: MSB Poll: Rank NFL QBs by Category (votes to date on page 4)

I just find it really boring. Most of the quarterbacks cannot throw, most of the kickers cannot kick, etc. Just not what I am looking for. Plus, half of the games are blowouts where Alabama throttles Bumblefrick State 63-3.

I just care about the players that go pro.

quote:

---

Fwiw, Brady has thrown less than 5 interceptions in a full season .

---

Can't say Drew can't be reckless at times, but if you watch a lot of saints games, about 1/3 of drews ints come off tipped passes that should of been caught. Also Drew is w/o Sean.

quote:

---

GOAT category:
Peyton Manning

---

quote:

---

TulaneTigerFan

---

shocking

Based off of this season

quote:

---

Top QBs in the game:
Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Peyton Manning
Aaron Rodgers

---

quote:

---

Very good and possibly elite QBs:
Jay Cutler
Joe Flacco
Eli Manning
Phillip Rivers
Ben Roethlesberger
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
Matt Schaub

---

quote:

---

Young QBs:
Sam Bradford
Andy Dalton
Josh Freeman
Colin Kaepernick
Jake Locker
Cam Newton
Christian Ponder
Matthew Stafford

---

This one is tough between Luck, RG3, and Wilson

quote:

---

Rookie QBs:
Robert Griffin
Andrew Luck
Ryan Tannehill
Brandon Weeden
Russell Wilson

---

quote:

---

I don't think people understand how much Rodgers is carrying this Packers team this year. He's played without his top 2 wideouts for most of the year, they're rotating in guys off the street at RB, and their defense is garbage without Matthews and Woodson. Don't get me started on his offensive line who were absolutely raped by the Seahawks and the Giants.

---

All of this.

Ranking by category...? Bleh... I'll just give my top 10.

1) Peyton
2) Brady
3) Rodgers
4) Brees
5) Eli
6) Big Ben
7) Matt Ryan
8) RG3
9) Joe Flacco
10) Tony Romo

A few notes on my top 10:

- Ranking Brees, Eli, and Big Ben is tough for me. Brees easily wins in statistics, but Ben and Eli both have the clutch plays in big time moments and each have one more ring than Brees. But I still put Brees above both.

- Matt Ryan better win a playoff game this year. Seriously.

- RG3 vaults above Ryan if he wins a playoff game this year, and Ryan doesn't.

- Joe Flacco is there for his clutch play that appears sporadically and his road playoff wins. Plus, the Ravens have not missed the playoffs with him as QB.

- Yep. Romo. Numbers don't lie. He has crapped the bed a bunch of times in his career. But he has quietly had his best season IMO this year. Regardless of what happens Sunday (I have RG3 and Washington winning), I still feel he has cemented himself as a top 10 QB.

quote:

---

If you're basing it off this season, Rodgers has more TDs than both Manning & Brady, 3 less INTs than Manning, and the same amount as Brady. He once again is the highest rated passer in the NFL.

His career numbers are insane.

65.7%
167 TDs
46 INTs
104.5 RAT

---

I think he is the best in the game currently, and has the widest skill set being mobile and unbelievably accurate. But, my MVP this year is Peyton Manning. To do what he has done, after sitting out a season and going to a new team is unbelievable. He has his team in grasp of the #1 seed in the AFC. Now, putting him over Brady is fine with me.

at Ryan being anything near an elite QB. He would top the scrub category though.

Considering the state of the saints this season I find it funny people are slamming Brees when he is about to become the first QB in history with over 5K yards passing and 40+ TDs in consecutive seasons.