I guess I mean expectations by Yankee standards.
Well, he is the best player on the Yankees by a good bit.
I honestly do not how much better you want him to get. He has been an absolute stud since he entered his peak at age 26. He has played at least 159 games every year since 2007.
In the last four seasons, he has hit at least:
These numbers represent the WORST he has done in each of these stats since 2009. He is doing this while playing second base. He is far and away the best second bagger in the league. Honestly, I think he will make the Hall of Fame.