re: Batman vs Captain America - Who wins?

quote:

---

Batman will use some obscure plot device to always win,

---

There's a reason they kept removing Bruce from the Cape and Cowl over the last few years. Gordon, Dick, etc.

Bruce became a plot device. And a bad one.

Indeed, I mean Lex Luthor is Superman's arch nemesis and his attributes are being a resourceful and well-to-do genius correct?

Batman. Without breaking a sweat.

captain America easily.

Almost any hero or villain with actual powers would kill him easily. And some without powers (iron man). I don't care who he beat in comics. The writers will and do obviously make him win but he would lose to most everyone.

quote:

---

Batman is an all time great character when taking on gangs, a corrupt system, nutjobs, etc. He's one of the worst characters when really superpowered characters are introduced

---

This same thing is apparent when The Flash shows up in the Arrow series.

If the two of them all of a sudden decided to duke it out Cap would win.
But if they knew they were going to fight even a little before hand, than I think Batman would win. He's taken on plenty of super humans before, and his key talent is being probably the best strategist out there.

quote:

---

If the Flash decided Batman had to go, he'd stroll in, stick a knife in his jugular, and go have a cup of coffee before Batman would hit the ground.

---

Okay, but Flash is even quicker than Superman. So all he would need to do is get a little kryptonite and cut Superman's throat with it right? He could cut Cap's throat or the Hulk's throat, etc.

So Flash > unbeatable?

Yes Flash should be able to beat almost anyone else. Flash with kryptonite should kill Superman easily. Flash with a pocketknife should kill most others.

quote:

---

quote:
If the Flash decided Batman had to go, he'd stroll in, stick a knife in his jugular, and go have a cup of coffee before Batman would hit the ground.


Okay, but Flash is even quicker than Superman. So all he would need to do is get a little kryptonite and cut Superman's throat with it right? He could cut Cap's throat or the Hulk's throat, etc.

So Flash > unbeatable?

---

Well, since you asked... cutting the Hulk's throat shouldn't do as much as the Hulk sticking a gun in his mouth and pulling the trigger. Going by the movies (Avengers), he did that and just spit the bullet out. Hulk heals. I don't know if the Hulk has a damage threshold where he breaks down; if he does, he will lose. The Flash can simply literally whittle him down. But if he just keeps regenerating and getting angrier, there's no finishing shot the Flash has.
As long as the Flash has the endurance, he holds out. But sooner or later, he will tire out, and one landed blow finishes him off.

Vs Superman- he's faster in some versions, but not in all, and not necessarily by a lot. And Supes has flight, heat vision, FAR greater durability and the lack of concern with breathing to factor in. And don't forget the super-heightened senses, he can detect things around the globe if he wants to, so he can hear the Flash coming. So depending on how much difference in speed there is, Superman can likely tank out and eventually land a hit. Remember, "kryptonite" is necessary to keep him from being totally invincible at every level.

But also consider, regarding the Flash, you can't lose if you never get hit. As long as he faces someone he can damage, he will win.

I thought DC did something awhile back, with "evil" Superman (Superboy Prime). That dude kicked everyone's arse, but he couldn't handle the Flash, until he got tired and slowed down.