2 trade proposals from same Manager UPDATE 8/22 9:30 AM

12 team Standard non PPR

My Lineup:

Brees
V Jax
T Austin
Spiller
McFadden
Witten
Mendenhall
Den K
CIN Def

His:

Luck
B Marshall
Torrey Smith
AP
Chris Ivory
Graham
Daryl Rich
K
no def yet


We have been in discussions in two scenarios:

1) Luck, Torrey Smith and Jimmy G for Brees, CIN Def and Witten

2)Luck and Marshall for Brees and CIN DEF

Either scenario means I lose Brees and CIN Def (don't care about the DEF), but one gives me Jimmy G and I plug my hole at WR2 while the other gives me Brandon Marshall for my WR2 while losing Brees for Luck and keeping Witten.

I'm not sure it's a good idea at all much less which one to go with.

Thoughts? TIA

UPDATE Luck and Marshall scenario taken off the board.

So that leaves me with:

Brees, Lance Moore, Witten, CIN Def for Luck, Torrey Smith, Jimmy Graham as my option and I'm thinking I could get him to switch Daryl Richardson for Rashard Mendenhall in the deal as well. I'm not high on Mendy for my RB3 and I think D Rich will have a great year now that he beat out the others for the starting job.

Thoughts?