re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

quote:

---

House Reed:

---

Go Gators!

I think King can legit, at Lord of House request,(Ramsey) or at request of bastard in absentia (Jon)

Stannis offered to Legit Jon and give him Winterfell as a bribe. Noone knows who Robb named yet for sure- he hinted it would be Jon.

IIRC. Been a while.

Have been rereading GoT. When Jon first sees Jaime in Winterfell he says, "he looks like a king" and GRRM put that in italics.

Foreshadowing? Any chance Jaime becomes king at some point, even for a short while?

I have been doing some re-reading of Dunk and Egg and I really think that their story is too crucial to the main story line to be over looked by HBO.

I am starting to think that they are going to take a year off and make Dunk and Egg movies. It's either that or they spend damn near an entire episode explaining the Blackfyre Rebellion and the significance of Bloodraven. I think that the richness of the story will be too much for the show to handle without an outside source. I think about how many times I had to reread the family trees to appreciate the Blackfyre rebellion's characters and I just dont think that is something you can do with a quick scene in the series.

I know that this will all rely on the premise of Varys being a Blackfyre, but I just don't think the show can hit home very well without that back story. The only option will be that Benioff and Weiss just skip this backstory completely, making the 3EC just a mystic character and Varys just a Targ sympathizer.

quote:

---

So Jon thinks Jaime looks like a king, and he's wearing Targaryen colors.

---

Lannister crimson, but i see your point

quote:

---

Noone knows who Robb named yet for sure- he hinted it would be Jon.

---

Maege and the Glovers know about the will and have it in their possession. I have a feeling it will pop up again soon

Time to do the Good and it's Complicated

The good list is a charaters that I believe to be inherently good, most are not without fault but can be considered genuinely good.

The lists are tentative and subject to change.


The Good
Davos Seaworth
Jon Snow
Samwell Tarly
Brienne of Tarth
*Maester Aemon Targaryen
*Maester Luwin
*Rhaegar Targaryen
Daenerys Targaryen (I still hate her)
*Ned Stark
*Lyanna Stark
*Robb Stark
Sansa Stark
Arya Stark
Rickon Stark
Bran Stark
Osha
Jojen Reed
Meera Reed
Howland Reed
Hodor
Coldhands
Wyman Manderly
Dolorous Edd
*Jon Arryn
Loras Tyrell
Margaery Tyrell
Thoros of Myr
Beric Dondarrion
Grey Worm
Barriston Selmy
*Arthur Dayne
Stannis Baratheon (may get some heat over this one)
Jaime Lannister (I'll get some heat over this one)
Podrick Payne
Gendry
*Jeor Mormont
Jorah Mormont
Jon Connington
Aegon Targaryen (little griff)
Strong Belwas
Donal Noye








It's Complicated/Unknown
Varys
Illyrio
Tyrion Lannister
*Ygritte
Mance Rayder
*Catelyn Tully Stark
*Robert Baratheon
*Renly Baratheon
Melisandre
Lancel Lannister
The Hound
Almost all the Martells
Asha Greyjoy
Theon Greyjoy
Jaqen H'ghar
Daario Naharis
Tormund Giantsbane
Bronn
Ilyn Payne
Randall Tarley
Bloodraven
Olenna Redwyne Tyrell
The Brotherhood without Banners
Bowen Marsh






The Bad
Ramsey Bolton
Roose Bolton
Almost all the Freys
Cersei Lannister
*Janos Slynt
Allister Thorne
*Tywin Lannister
Gregor Clegane
All the Bloody Murmmers
*Joffery Lannister
Peytr Baelish
*Grand Maester Pycelle
*Viserys Targaryen
*Aerys II Targayen
*Balon Greyjoy
Euron Greyjoy
*Craster
*Lysa Tulley
Qyburn
*Rattleshirt
The Others

quote:

---

Question: do we know how Melisandre got her paws on Lightbringer, and even if it actually is the actual sword Azor Ahai used?

---

im pretty sure she just used a random sword or Stannis's sword to "recreate" Lightbringer (in the ceremony where they burned the 7 statues of the gods)

which is why Maester Aemon points out to Sam that he doesnt think the sword is actually Lightbringer because it gives off no heat, it only shines