Solution for Dreamers

I've continually heard many people saying that we can't kick out the Dreamers because most of them grew up their whole childhood here and don't even know or never set foot in their family's country of origin. While that's a sad thought on an individual basis, it is not an excuse to ignore law breaking.

I have a proposal however:

Dreamers that arrived under the age of of 12 years old and have since remained in the US for at least a total of 5 years or more shall be granted partial permanent residence status. Any child that has not been in the US at least 5 years at the time of enactment of this law, shall be removed to their native land. What does that mean? It is some rights granted to permanent residents with several key things removed:

1) No path to citizenship, period. Which means no voting rights at all.

2) Cannot grant a spouse any legal status through marriage nor to children that were not born in the US.

3) You cannot use any governmental services unless you are working and paying taxes above what you consume (i.e. you can't net take from the government).

4) You have no right to sponsor any family members for any form of immigration to the US.

5) Parents that brought the child(ren) to the US will be immediately deported if here and will never be allowed to re-enter the US for any reason short of legitimate assylum/refugee claims.

These are some examples of how this can work without completely kicking them out but limiting the benefit they get from breaking the law. It's a work in progress but can also be a starting point to limit the abuse of the system while showing some semblance of compassion.