Fantasy Baseball Keeper help (auction value keepers)

We keep 2 players in my league and it is closing in on time for a keeper decision. 12 team league, head to head 5x5 scoring. We have a $260 budget for the draft, the keeper costs come out of your draft budget.


The way the keepers work in this league is a player on your final roster can be kept for last years draft value plus an inflation fee ($3 this year). If the player was not drafted last year, they can be kept for $0+$3 inflation.


These are the players I am considering, and their relevant cost for me ( I have factored in the inflation to each value listed below).

Jose Bautista at $24
George Springer at $3
Kyle Seager at $13

I also had Adam Jones to consider but he would cost me $38 to keep which is not worth it.


So my basic question is, do I keep Bautista for a little less than half of his default 12 team auction value, or keeper Seager for $13 due to position scarcity? I think springer is a lock to keep at $3.


ETA: Didn't realize someone drafted seager last year for $10, so my cost to keep him would be $13