Who was a better coach while at LSU, Dale Brown or Charlie Mac?

I know some will think this is too much "apples and oranges" but those who have thoughts please share to help setttle dispute with my brother in law.
The question is, who was the better coach (i.e. wins, run the program, reflect well for LSU, know when to leave, recruit, game coach, develop talent)for LSU?

The facts as we see them are:

CM- 137-59 (70%) as HC 17 years, asst coach 1953-61. 60-41 (60%) in SEC, 7-6 bowls, one SEC champ, one losing record (forfeits incl) won 55% last 6 years, inherited very good team/tradition, stayed too long

DB- 448-301 (60%) in 25 years, 238-200 in SEC (54%) 4 sec reg season champs, one sec trny, 13 NCAA's but only 4 times made it past round 2, two probations, one minor, one major, last 4 years had losing record, inherited 10-16 team with little tradition. But stayed too long

IMHO CM is at least as good as Dale for LSU (brother in law says DB MUCH better). My reasons are DB did build a program, but underachived most years and got us on probation 2 times, and left us in bad shape. CM hardly beat Bama, but no one could then and he never had us in trouble with NCAA. CM winning % better in SEC and overall. To the non-LSU world (which I think needs to be considered) Brown's reputation was as much positive as negative. I am thankful for both and appreciate they both did a lot of very good things for LSU, glad they both were here. BUT think Brown gets too much credit and CM not enough. Fire away, am I wrong?