Sproles or Bush?

Sproles but only because of Bush's injury concerns. If I am guaranteed a healthy game out of both of them, I take Bush.

Sproles is perfect for the Saints offense.

I just love Bush's ability to make moves after the catch. His injury concerns do worry me slightly.

bush is a little more talented, sproles is a lot more durable. ill take sproles for this team, but dont think my answer would be the same for all 32.

Sproles and this is not even close.

Reggie, and it's not that close. He's bigger, stronger, and more versatile.

Did any of you see his long TD run Sunday? I don't think Sproles would be physically capable of something like that. For whatever reason Reggie wasn't as good as Sproles has been for the Saints though, whether he had growing pains and needed time to adjust or it was a usage issue

quote:

---

but dont think my answer would be the same for all 32.

---

Exactly, Bush is in the perfect situation in Detroit [and even the short time in Miami] wasn't that bad.

Sproles is awesome in NOLA. But, I could also see him doing well in San Fran & Seattle's offense.

Did you see the post I responded to? It's more realistic to say it isn't close in Reggie's favor than Sproles.

Reggie proved capable of being an every down back in Miami. He's missed 1.5 games this season and is still on pace for over 2,100 yards from scrimmage. He's a legit threat both on the ground and in the passing game.

Reggie Bush

For the Saints offense, Sproles is the perfect back. He's how they wanted to utilize Bush, and while he had his moments, he just didn't fit in as well. Payton really knows how to use Sproles, and he relies on using the running back by committee.

Bush is a perfect fit for Detroit. He's on a team that is set in a spread offense, and they can constantly pick spots to use him in space.

I will always hope the best for Reggie, but I wouldn't trade Sproles for him in the offense. That really just has to do with the scheme. For overall talent, and for many other teams, you take Reggie. They are both dynamic players though.

Bush has definetly "matured" as a RB. He's much better now that he's not trying to play "hero ball" every time he touches it. The game has slowed down for him.

Just imagine how much more dangerous Sproles would be if the Saints could actually run block? The only negative about Sproles (and actually I don't consider it that much of a negative) is that 90% of the time Sproles in in there, the play is gonna be a pass. But that being said, he's fricking unguardable. Brees could get him the ball any time he wants.