| Posted by | Message |
tigerpimpbot 
LA-Monroe Fan
Judicial hell hole 1
Member since Nov 2011
14046 posts
| Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 12:25 am)
Who do you prefer?
Singing and guitar vs. lyrics and arrangement
|
| Back to top | Share on  |
BRUNNIN4 
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Mar 2010
1661 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 12:33 am to tigerpimpbot)
Gilmour
|
| Back to top | |
tigerpimpbot
LA-Monroe Fan
Judicial hell hole 1
Member since Nov 2011
14046 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 12:41 am to BRUNNIN4)
I agree
|
| Back to top | |
Ryne Sandberg 
USA Fan
Team Am Mart
Member since Apr 2009
16379 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 12:48 am to tigerpimpbot)
David Gilmour because he's not a whiny twat.
|
| Back to top | |
mograyback 
Missouri Fan
Red Patoka Sea
Member since Jul 2011
5481 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 1:00 am to tigerpimpbot)
Gilmour.
|
| Back to top | |
The Dude's Rug
LSU Fan
Fourside
Member since Nov 2004
3491 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 1:39 am to tigerpimpbot)
Gilmour in every category.
Waters is a weird frick.
|
| Back to top | |
squirtis42 
Mississippi St. Fan
Member since Sep 2012
42 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 2:02 am to tigerpimpbot)
Gilmour no doubt.
|
| Back to top | |
CocoLoco 
New Orleans Saints Fan
30° 12' N 92° 0' W
Member since Jan 2012
7540 posts
 Online
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 2:28 am to tigerpimpbot)
Gilmour is magic
|
| Back to top | |
White Shadeaux
LSU Fan
In the nicest parts of hell
Member since Jan 2006
22026 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 7:56 am to CocoLoco)
I like their collaborations, but Waters' personal little child angst therapy moments just about ruin The Wall for me.
Gilmour all the way.
|
| Back to top | |
CottonWasKing
LSU Fan
4,8,15,16,23,42
Member since Jun 2011
12702 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:02 am to tigerpimpbot)
Gilmour
|
| Back to top | |
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
15611 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:17 am to tigerpimpbot)
I prefer Roger. Pink Floyd without him became extremely boring.
|
| Back to top | |
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
15611 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:18 am to The Dude's Rug)
quote:
Gilmour in every category.
Gilmour is nowhere near the songwriter that Waters is.
|
| Back to top | |
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
15611 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:19 am to Ryne Sandberg)
quote:
David Gilmour......not a whiny twat.
The problem with Floyd was that both of them are arrogant pricks.
|
| Back to top | |
xgd
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Nov 2010
269 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:23 am to Jester)
quote:
Gilmour is nowhere near the songwriter that Waters is.
|
| Back to top | |
Scruffy
USA Fan
Team Hugo Stiglitz 4 Life
Member since Jul 2011
17603 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:41 am to tigerpimpbot)
Both are great in their own way. As of late, I'd probably go with Gilmour since I've been enjoying Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell.
|
| Back to top | |
White Shadeaux
LSU Fan
In the nicest parts of hell
Member since Jan 2006
22026 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 8:53 am to Scruffy)
quote:
Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell.
But wait....Jester says those are extremely boring. 
|
| Back to top | |
PuntBamaPunt 
Vanderbilt Fan
Member since Nov 2010
4668 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 9:08 am to White Shadeaux)
I like both of those albums but they aren't near the albums the group as a whole put out.
To claim Gilmour is a better songwriter than Waters is absurd.
|
| Back to top | |
legba 
Alabama Fan
at the crossroads
Member since Oct 2010
521 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 9:11 am to PuntBamaPunt)
Waters, but only by a hair. I would hate anaimals if not for Dave's guitar work
|
| Back to top | |
Jester
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
15611 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 9:13 am to PuntBamaPunt)
quote:
I like both of those albums but they aren't near the albums the group as a whole put out.
To claim Gilmour is a better songwriter than Waters is absurd.
Exactly. FWIW, I own both albums and don't dislike them. They are just not on par with previous work. Quite frankly, they are the Pink Floyd albums I am most likely to play to help me fall asleep at night.
The Division Bell is actually the first album on my "Sleepytime" playlist.
This post was edited on 1/4 at 9:17 am
|
| Back to top | |
SUB
LSU Fan
Member since Jan 2009
2292 posts
| re: Pink Floyd fans, Roger Waters or David Gilmour (Posted on 1/4/13 at 9:18 am to Jester)
Gilmour has a great voice but Rogers is a better song writer. I like the combination of them both.
|
| Back to top | |
