How good is Mcneil compared to D smith? | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Smaug the Terrible
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2012
9 posts

How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?



Are his ball skill good?







Back to top
Share:
sunnydaze
New Orleans Saints Fan
over the hills
Member since Jan 2010
14933 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


Smith is better





Back to top
jocvh
LSU Fan
Las Vegas
Member since Dec 2011
337 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


quote:

Smith is better


But having to big guys that can actually catch the ball will really help Rettig and/or Jennings.

(If he can qualify and we accept his commit, fingers crossed)






Back to top
Smaug the Terrible
LSU Fan
Member since Dec 2012
9 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


Pretty impressive offer list. Both of them will be great players





Back to top
  Replies (0)
LsuTool
Columbia Fan
Suck that tiger Tool, B
Member since Oct 2009
22723 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


quote:

But having to big guys that can actually catch the ball will really help Rettig and/or Jennings.


Our coaches can hardly use 1 TE, you think they gonna go all New England Patriots with 2 TEs in the future? I doubt it. I'm happy with 1 TE that has good ball skills. With Dickson and Smith on campus, we should have at least 1.






Back to top
Gravitiger
LSU Fan
Member since Jun 2011
3032 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


Happy with one, but would be happier with more.

McNeil is more of an all-around guy. Smith is more of a pure flex TE.






Back to top
jocvh
LSU Fan
Las Vegas
Member since Dec 2011
337 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


quote:

Happy with one, but would be happier with more.

McNeil is more of an all-around guy. Smith is more of a pure flex TE.


This






Back to top
  Replies (0)
RATeamWannabe
USA Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2009
15088 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


Considering Smith will actually be part if this class and McNeil has a lot of work to do, I say Smith>





Back to top
phison
Member since Dec 2011
605 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


Smith is the pass catching flex TE.
McNeil is the more well rounded in line blocking/some pass catching TE

I like smith as the better prospect (and hes already in this class and definitely gonna make it to campus) but McNeil has some great potential as well






Back to top
  Replies (0)
coldhotwings
Temple Fan
Mississippi
Member since Jan 2008
6438 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


Think of McNeil as a bigger and better Cethan Carter whom the staff likes a lot.





Back to top
  Replies (0)
Cousin
LSU Fan
The Bayou
Member since Feb 2012
4606 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


quote:

you think they gonna go all New England Patriots with 2 TEs in the future






Back to top
  Replies (0)
GetmorewithLes
LSU Fan
UK Basketball Fan
Member since Jan 2011
2859 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


quote:

you think they gonna go all New England Patriots with 2 TEs in the future?


What team have you been watching? LSU runs two and three TE sets all the time. What if these guys could actually be threats to run a route, get open, and make a catch. Would enhance run game as well as overall offensive effectiveness.






Back to top
drjeff17
LSU Fan
lake charles, la.
Member since Aug 2008
1025 posts

re: How good is Mcneil compared to D smith?


New England Patriots lite! Won't it surprise the hell out of defenses when two guys they expect to block are running free down the middle seams.





Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top