| Posted by | Message |
Rex 
LSU Fan
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
47740 posts
| What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 9:41 pm)
There are a lot of good singers in America... few great ones. I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows (aside from Christina Aguillera and a few celebrity guests, that is.)
|
| Back to top | Share on  |
Tino 
Duke Fan
:yawn:
Member since Dec 2004
70984 posts
 Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 9:43 pm to Rex)
You must not have seen Carly Rose on the x factor then
|
| Back to top | |
Fearthehat0307
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
32117 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 9:45 pm to Rex)
quote:
I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows
you obviously arent watching x factor this year. carly rose might be one of the greatest singers to exist
|
| Back to top | |
LuckySo-n-So
LSU Fan
Member since Jul 2005
12188 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 9:50 pm to Rex)
quote:
I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows
While I don't know who Carly Rose is, I would suggest that American Idol has showcased a number of great singers. They may not all be successful, but they are most assuredly great voices. Including, but not limited to:
Kelly Clarkson
Kimberly Locke
Clay Aiken
Carrie Underwood
Fantasia Barrino
among others. I haven't watched in several years because the show sucks donkey arse now.
I've never been impressed with anyone I've seen on any of the other shows, including "The Voice"
|
| Back to top | |
Sammobile
LSU Fan
Hollywood South
Member since Jan 2009
19021 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 9:56 pm to LuckySo-n-So)
Javier Colon from The Voice(season 1) is great singer. He won't ever be a "star" but he is great at what he does.
|
| Back to top | |
unbeWEAVEable
LSU Fan
Golf Board
Member since Apr 2010
8509 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 10:15 pm to Rex)
How about Susan Boyle?
|
| Back to top | |
iluvdatiger
LSU Fan
Ridgeland, MS
Member since Jan 2004
32623 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 10:18 pm to Rex)
Carly Rose is the best singer out of all three shows.
|
| Back to top | |
BuckeyeFan87 
Ohio State Fan
Columbus
Member since Dec 2007
19289 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 10:36 pm to Rex)
Carley Rose Sonenclar disagrees.
|
| Back to top | |
Jim Rockford
LSU Fan
Member since May 2011
23332 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 10:51 pm to Rex)
The great ones have other options of getting where they're going besides auditioning on a reality show.
|
| Back to top | |
F machine 
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Jun 2009
10984 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 10:55 pm to LuckySo-n-So)
Jennifer Hudson was on American idol. Op is an idiot, but I think most people here know that already.
|
| Back to top | |
VOR
New Orleans Saints Fan
New Orleans
Member since Apr 2009
33144 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 10:56 pm to Rex)
quote:
I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows
You haven't watched closely enough.
|
| Back to top | |
TheRig 
Auburn Fan
Atlanta Braves Advocate
Member since Aug 2011
18638 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:09 pm to Rex)
quote:
I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows (aside from Christina Aguillera and a few celebrity guests, that is.)
Hey Rex, your stupidity is showing.. again.
|
| Back to top | |
BeeFense5 
Notre Dame Fan
New Orleans
Member since Jul 2010
15829 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:11 pm to Rex)
American idol gave us Carrie Underwood and Hollie Cavanagh. Two of the greatest singers of all time. 
|
| Back to top | |
Fearthehat0307
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
32117 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:14 pm to BeeFense5)
quote:
American idol gave us Carrie Underwood and Hollie Cavanagh. Two of the greatest singers of all time.
carly rose voice >>>>>>>>>>>>>> both of them combined
|
| Back to top | |
BeeFense5
Notre Dame Fan
New Orleans
Member since Jul 2010
15829 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:16 pm to Fearthehat0307)
quote:
carly rose voice >>>>>>>>>>>>>> both of them combined
Underwood >>> Carly Rose
But carly rose is good and I think she should win. She's just getting a little too hyped due to poor competition.
|
| Back to top | |
Rex
LSU Fan
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
47740 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:38 pm to LuckySo-n-So)
quote:
Kelly Clarkson Kimberly Locke Clay Aiken Carrie Underwood Fantasia Barrino
Like I said... good singers, not great.
|
| Back to top | |
saintsfan92612
New Orleans Saints Fan
a pretty good city
Member since Oct 2008
16600 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:43 pm to Rex)
holy shite. Ya'll weren't kidding about Carly Rose. I just youtubed here and she is damn good.
|
| Back to top | |
just1dawg 
Mississippi St. Fan
Enzed
Member since Dec 2011
334 posts
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/2/12 at 11:46 pm to unbeWEAVEable)
quote:
How about Susan Boyle?
Susan Boyle's story was perfectly played up by Simon Cowell & Co. and it was a truly epic few minutes of televions when the frumpy middle aged woman from West Lothian (which is a collection of, of of, of, you know....villages!) showed that in her own beautiful she had serious star power and a nice set of pipes.
Unfortunately she also has that middle aged vocal wobble that causes annoying vibrato and let's be honest...she's pretty frumpy.
Still a great triumph for someone who richly deserved it and her debut album made her some serious $$$$.
|
| Back to top | |
Fearthehat0307
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
32117 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/3/12 at 12:00 am to BeeFense5)
quote:
Underwood >>> Carly Rose
in what way? if you are talking vocal talent you are more delusional than the gumps
This post was edited on 12/3 at 12:01 am
|
| Back to top | |
Fearthehat0307
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
32117 posts
Online
| re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me. (Posted on 12/3/12 at 12:06 am to Fearthehat0307)
carly rose - my heart will go on
carly rose - somewhere over the rainbow
carly rose - rolling in the deep
these 3 links are the last 3 performances from carly rose sonenclair. they easily disprove rex and beefense's claims
This post was edited on 12/3 at 12:07 am
|
| Back to top | |
