Posted byMessage
Rex
LSU Fan
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
52409 posts

What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


There are a lot of good singers in America... few great ones. I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows (aside from Christina Aguillera and a few celebrity guests, that is.)






Back to top
Share:
Tino
Southeastern LA Fan
:yawn:
Member since Dec 2004
75543 posts
 Online 

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


You must not have seen Carly Rose on the x factor then





Back to top
Fearthehat0307
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
44814 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows
you obviously arent watching x factor this year. carly rose might be one of the greatest singers to exist






Back to top
LuckySo-n-So
LSU Fan
A corner in Winslow, Arizona
Member since Jul 2005
14347 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows


While I don't know who Carly Rose is, I would suggest that American Idol has showcased a number of great singers. They may not all be successful, but they are most assuredly great voices. Including, but not limited to:

Kelly Clarkson
Kimberly Locke
Clay Aiken
Carrie Underwood
Fantasia Barrino

among others. I haven't watched in several years because the show sucks donkey arse now.

I've never been impressed with anyone I've seen on any of the other shows, including "The Voice"






Back to top
Sammobile
New Orleans Saints Fan
Somewhere in America..
Member since Jan 2009
20024 posts
 Online 

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


Javier Colon from The Voice(season 1) is great singer. He won't ever be a "star" but he is great at what he does.





Back to top
unbeWEAVEable
LSU Fan
Golf Board
Member since Apr 2010
10591 posts
 Online 

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


How about Susan Boyle?





Back to top
iluvdatiger
LSU Fan
Ridgeland, MS
Member since Jan 2004
36503 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


Carly Rose is the best singer out of all three shows.





Back to top
BuckeyeFan87
USA Fan
Columbus
Member since Dec 2007
21365 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


Carley Rose Sonenclar disagrees.





Back to top
Jim Rockford
LSU Fan
Member since May 2011
32070 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


The great ones have other options of getting where they're going besides auditioning on a reality show.





Back to top
F machine
New Orleans Saints Fan
Member since Jun 2009
11885 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


Jennifer Hudson was on American idol. Op is an idiot, but I think most people here know that already.





Back to top
VOR
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
New Orleans
Member since Apr 2009
39490 posts
 Online 

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows


You haven't watched closely enough.






Back to top
TheRig
Auburn Fan
@RigOnSECrant
Member since Aug 2011
23527 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

I have yet to see a great singer on any of those three shows (aside from Christina Aguillera and a few celebrity guests, that is.)
Hey Rex, your stupidity is showing.. again.






Back to top
BeeFense5
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Kenna
Member since Jul 2010
17008 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


American idol gave us Carrie Underwood and Hollie Cavanagh. Two of the greatest singers of all time.





Back to top
Fearthehat0307
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
44814 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

American idol gave us Carrie Underwood and Hollie Cavanagh. Two of the greatest singers of all time.
carly rose voice >>>>>>>>>>>>>> both of them combined






Back to top
BeeFense5
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Kenna
Member since Jul 2010
17008 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

carly rose voice >>>>>>>>>>>>>> both of them combined


Underwood >>> Carly Rose

But carly rose is good and I think she should win. She's just getting a little too hyped due to poor competition.






Back to top
Rex
LSU Fan
Here, there, and nowhere
Member since Sep 2004
52409 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

Kelly Clarkson Kimberly Locke Clay Aiken Carrie Underwood Fantasia Barrino

Like I said... good singers, not great.







Back to top
saintsfan92612
New Orleans Saints Fan
a pretty good city
Member since Oct 2008
17858 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


holy shite. Ya'll weren't kidding about Carly Rose. I just youtubed here and she is damn good.





Back to top
just1dawg
Mississippi St. Fan
Enzed
Member since Dec 2011
586 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

How about Susan Boyle?


Susan Boyle's story was perfectly played up by Simon Cowell & Co. and it was a truly epic few minutes of televions when the frumpy middle aged woman from West Lothian (which is a collection of, of of, of, you know....villages!) showed that in her own beautiful she had serious star power and a nice set of pipes.

Unfortunately she also has that middle aged vocal wobble that causes annoying vibrato and let's be honest...she's pretty frumpy.

Still a great triumph for someone who richly deserved it and her debut album made her some serious $$$$.






Back to top
Fearthehat0307
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
44814 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


quote:

Underwood >>> Carly Rose
in what way? if you are talking vocal talent you are more delusional than the gumps



This post was edited on 12/3 at 12:01 am


Back to top
Fearthehat0307
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Dec 2007
44814 posts

re: What American Idol, The Voice, and X Factor have taught me.


carly rose - my heart will go on


carly rose - somewhere over the rainbow

carly rose - rolling in the deep




these 3 links are the last 3 performances from carly rose sonenclair. they easily disprove rex and beefense's claims



This post was edited on 12/3 at 12:07 am


Back to top



Back to top