re: Transgender teen who was beaten by bullies now dreams of becoming a model

quote:

---

It might just be he hasn't learned enough to realize just how ignorant is on this topic. I think I could teach old doc a thing or 2 about this.

---

Dude you can't even figure out that I'm not a doctor even after I told you I'm not one. You gotta be trolling

Father must be proud

quote:

---

Dude you can't even figure out that I'm not a doctor even after I told you I'm not one.

---

quote:

---

I treat cancer patients for a living

---

Doctor, .. almost a doctor, ... read a few books on a subject and act like a doctor, ... who gives a shite!??! You are a narcist with a superiority complex. I don't have to prove anything to you BUT if you read what I wrote carefully you would have seen I used common terms to agree with you.

I simply don't agree that at any time should one validate these feelings that queer (look it up in the dictionary. There are few enough to qualify.) They are not normal and should never be allowed to think they are.

You still have no idea as to how much training I have on this ... and I don't care to share .... especially given your holier-than-though attitude based on a relatively little amount of reading.

quote:

---

Some people take comments like that way too personally

---

Nothing personal taken. It's not about me. It's about someone with no professional training nor personal dealings in a work or social environment declaring he knows more than others.

Reading the entire post reveals volumes on the personality of the individual.

I simply see a narcissist believing that he is somehow an expert based on having read some books. The information posted, however, reveals something entirely different.

Maybe he should read some more or chose better books.

quote:

---

Unless he's deliberately misleading me to believe he knows less than he really does, then I 'know' to a reasonable degree of confidence that I know more than he does about this. 

---

I have an uncle who has been a pre-op "aunt" since the early 90s, who lived with us for awhile because he had nowhere else to go. I would venture to say I know more than anyone else on this site who isn't a) a tranny or b) a mental health professional. Yet I have not been in here giving my 2 cents.

Why?

It isn't worth it. Trust me when I say it's shitty mental health science layered on top of things which good science has trouble figuring out, or what good science know and mental health science REFUSES to admit.

I'll say my piece once.

My uncle is 100% male, yet has a chest cavity closer in shape to a female, and he didn't start taking hormones till he was almost 30. However that is the only thing which physically even hints at being a female below the surface. His story to get to "gender dysphoria" is the same as most. As a young child, an adult tainted his mind by coaxing him into actions which altered his sense of reality. "Gender dysphoria" cases are 95% on adults, but no one wants to admit this in the industry. If you were to look at the role their upbringing played in their lives, I almost guarantee you would see a startlingly consistent narrative play out.

Especially in cases of male to female, which 3x more likely than female to male transitions. There is a reason why male to female transitions are skyrocketing in an age of shitty parenting, high divorce, and most importantly radical feminism, which has affected both a man's role in child rearing, and women's perspectives on gender roles. Even the perspectives of women who don't hold serve with the beliefs of the movement.

If I am not mistaken you heavily support gay rights. Just so happens radical feminism and gay rights truly can't work together. I've had the discussion with gay friends who are activists in the DC area. They maintain feminism is hurting their movement greatly. They also don't think the 2 movements can coexist in the same platform.

I could dig far deeper into this, and I'm simply giving a cursory overview of my stance, but there is the gist of it. I will add I am speaking strictly on so called gender dysphoria, not those who have legitimate birth defects clouding their gender.

I agree with Hill On A Hog.

You guys don't seem to understand. Biological sex and gender are not the same. Biological sex is determined by a person's DNA, however gender is determined by how a person feels. Therefore, a person, biologically is generally male or female; their gender can be comparatively different. Their gender could be female, though they are male, or male though they are female, or apple though they are female, or giraffe though they are male.

It's 2016, gender is ultimately a useless descriptor now. As Hog On The Hill pointed out, there's so much politically driven pseudoscientific babble attached to the topic that it would make flat earthers blush.

That's a lot of text to say I love penis.

quote:

---

That's a lot of text to just say "I'm a bigot."

---

This is why we can't have decent discourse in this country anymore. The second someone says something we disagree with, we instantly start shouting them down with name calling.

I am far from a bigot, and I'm not sure how you can read that and say I am. I have a transgender uncle who use to live with us, and I mentioned discussion with gay activists in the DC area who I call friends. Good friends actually.

quote:

---

As a gender fluid individual, loving penis empowers my femininist female side and defines my gay male side.

---

quote:

---

DanMullins4Life

---

This guy here. Man, I'm about to head to bed on that note. You win the internet. That was some funny shite.