Started By
Message

Military people, why are we still deploying national guard units to Afghanistan?

Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:29 am
Posted by GetCocky11
Calgary, AB
Member since Oct 2012
51242 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:29 am
I just read about a local National Guard unit that is being deployed to Afghanistan.

With such a low total troop commitment over there right now, why isn't the active Army handling this 100%?

Seems like a waste.
Posted by CelticDog
Member since Apr 2015
42867 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:32 am to
Let there be no doubt, common sense is not common in wartime.
On other hand reg army dont want three tours in 8 years. Draft is answer to endless war vs islam.
Posted by Fat and Happy
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2013
16965 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:36 am to
Because all units, at some point, take a turn and get in the fight.
Posted by Rhino5
Atlanta
Member since Nov 2014
28897 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:42 am to
We will never completely leave, same with Iraq. We built the largest embassy is the world in Baghdad capable of housing 5,500 troops, 104 acres.


Posted by GetCocky11
Calgary, AB
Member since Oct 2012
51242 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:43 am to
quote:

Because all units, at some point, take a turn and get in the fight.


I don't buy that with the National Guard. Active and Reserves, sure. But, if the government feels the need to deploy a National Guard unit overseas to an area with a current troop commitment of less than 10,000, then I find that to be a questionable use of resources.
Posted by TigerFanInSouthland
Louisiana
Member since Aug 2012
28065 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:44 am to
quote:

We built the largest embassy is the world in Baghdad capable of housing 5,500 troops, 104 acres.


That seems like a bit much.
Posted by magildachunks
Member since Oct 2006
32479 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:44 am to
Better question: why are we being asked to donate toiletries? Shouldn't the military provide those?
Posted by CHEDBALLZ
South Central LA
Member since Dec 2009
21909 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 7:56 am to
Because Afghanistan is home to one of the worlds largest deposits of Lithium. That's why we aren't at war with North Korea, we have enough rice.
Posted by Bullfrog
Institutionalized but Unevaluated
Member since Jul 2010
56167 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:03 am to
To protect the poppy crop. Military Industrial complex needs the money.
Posted by unbeWEAVEable
The Golf Board Godfather
Member since Apr 2010
13637 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:04 am to
quote:

I just read about a local National Guard unit that is being deployed to Afghanistan.

With such a low total troop commitment over there right now, why isn't the active Army handling this 100%?

Seems like a waste.


The people who can answer this question won't because of OPSEC. Any other answer with detailed information is hopefully false.
Posted by 13SaintTiger
Isle of Capri
Member since Sep 2011
18315 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:08 am to
BLUF: The Army is going through a phase where they are experimenting with NG and Reserve units being on equal footing with Active. See the recent realignment with 10th mountain and Texas NG and 173rd ABN. Government believes it makes the Army more well-rounded.

My opinion: It's stupid as frick and wasteful.

Posted by CaptainBrannigan
Good Ole Rocky Top Tennessee
Member since Jan 2010
21644 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:09 am to
Everyone has to do their part in the military-industrial complex. How else will those who profiteer from war turn a profit?
Posted by GetCocky11
Calgary, AB
Member since Oct 2012
51242 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:11 am to
quote:

BLUF: The Army is going through a phase where they are experimenting with NG and Reserve units being on equal footing with Active. See the recent realignment with 10th mountain and Texas NG and 173rd ABN. Government believes it makes the Army more well-rounded.

My opinion: It's stupid as frick and wasteful.


That sounds idiotic.

Isn't the National Guard basically a state militia full of guys with full-time careers outside the military? Why would they want to put these guys on an equal footing as an active duty soldier?

Posted by CajunSoldier225
Member since Aug 2011
8990 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:12 am to
Deployments are about to increase. Not just in the ME.

So, to answer your question logically, there are not enough troops to go around so the Guard fills the gap.
Posted by Tiger Prawn
Member since Dec 2016
21856 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:14 am to
quote:

Better question: why are we being asked to donate toiletries? Shouldn't the military provide those?


To guarantee that the troops have soft 2-ply TP instead of that cheap crap the government buys.
Posted by lsucoonass
shreveport and east texas
Member since Nov 2003
68446 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:15 am to
well national guard units are combat arms
not all units in active duty are combat arms

there are some really good national guard units that can effectively get the job done.
Posted by PeaRidgeWatash
Down by the docks of the city
Member since Dec 2004
15210 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:15 am to
At last count, we have more than 650 military bases around the world. Staffing those with an average of 500 troops puts the number up to 325,000.
Posted by lsucoonass
shreveport and east texas
Member since Nov 2003
68446 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:16 am to
most Army reserve units are not combat arms, so there probably isnt a need to bring a whole brigade or battalion to Afghanistan.
Posted by AFtigerFan
Ohio
Member since Feb 2008
3248 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:49 am to
The good old Army National Guard. I'll never forget when they arrived at FOB Lightning, went on a mission, and called for fire on themselves on accident. Troop movements in the theater were shut down for a week while everyone had to do remedial training and have a fire control officer on every convoy. What a shite show they were.
Posted by lsucoonass
shreveport and east texas
Member since Nov 2003
68446 posts
Posted on 8/24/17 at 8:58 am to
ive been to fob lightning before.

come to think of it i been to many of them in RC East whether it is by convoy or by black hawk.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram