- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Where do you rank Carr as far as returning QBs
Posted on 2/14/23 at 1:51 pm
Posted on 2/14/23 at 1:51 pm
There has been a lot of discussion of how good or how bad of a QB Carr is. So where do you rank him as a QB? Below is every QB who started a game in 2022 (with games started) besides Brady who is retiring.
What is your rank for Carr? Not just last year, but who do you want taking over for your team next year.
Top 10
Patrick Mahomes (16)
Joe Burrow (15)
Aaron Rodgers (16)
Josh Allen (15)
Jalen Hurts (14)
Justin Herbert (16)
Lamar Jackson (12)
Deshaun Watson (5)
Matthew Stafford (9)
Kirk Cousins (16)
11-15
Russell Wilson (14)
Jimmy Garoppolo (10)
Trevor Lawrence (16)
Derek Carr (15)
Dak Prescott (11)
16-20
Tua Tagovailoa (13)
Ryan Tannehill (12)
Daniel Jones (16)
Jared Goff (16)
Geno Smith (16)
Next 21-30
Davis Mills (14)
Andy Dalton (13)
Mac Jones (13)
Brock Purdy (4)
Jameis Winston (3)
Baker Mayfield (3)
Justin Fields (15)
Kyler Murray (11)
Taylor Heinicke (9)
Kenny Pickett (11)
31-40
Jacoby Brissett (11)
Cooper Rush (5)
Sam Ehlinger (2)
Bailey Zappe (2)
Matt Ryan (12)
Carson Wentz (7)
Teddy Bridgewater (2)
Marcus Mariota (13)
Mitchell Trubisky (5)
Malik Willis (3)
Remainder
Trevor Siemian (1)
Brett Rypien (2)
Colt McCoy (3)
Trace McSorley (1)
David Blough (1)
Nick Foles (2)
Skylar Thompson (1)
Gardner Minshew (2)
Desmond Ridder (3)
Trey Lance (2)
Zach Wilson (9)
Mike White (4)
Joe Flacco (3)
Sam Darnold (5)
P.J. Walker (5)
Jarrett Stidham (1)
John Wolford (3)
Bryce Perkins (1)
Tyler Huntley (4)
Kyle Allen (2)
Jeff Driskel (2)
Joshua Dobbs (1)
This is my order that I put together quickly. But generally, I think it’s pretty close to the order I’d finish with.
What is your rank for Carr? Not just last year, but who do you want taking over for your team next year.
Top 10
Patrick Mahomes (16)
Joe Burrow (15)
Aaron Rodgers (16)
Josh Allen (15)
Jalen Hurts (14)
Justin Herbert (16)
Lamar Jackson (12)
Deshaun Watson (5)
Matthew Stafford (9)
Kirk Cousins (16)
11-15
Russell Wilson (14)
Jimmy Garoppolo (10)
Trevor Lawrence (16)
Derek Carr (15)
Dak Prescott (11)
16-20
Tua Tagovailoa (13)
Ryan Tannehill (12)
Daniel Jones (16)
Jared Goff (16)
Geno Smith (16)
Next 21-30
Davis Mills (14)
Andy Dalton (13)
Mac Jones (13)
Brock Purdy (4)
Jameis Winston (3)
Baker Mayfield (3)
Justin Fields (15)
Kyler Murray (11)
Taylor Heinicke (9)
Kenny Pickett (11)
31-40
Jacoby Brissett (11)
Cooper Rush (5)
Sam Ehlinger (2)
Bailey Zappe (2)
Matt Ryan (12)
Carson Wentz (7)
Teddy Bridgewater (2)
Marcus Mariota (13)
Mitchell Trubisky (5)
Malik Willis (3)
Remainder
Trevor Siemian (1)
Brett Rypien (2)
Colt McCoy (3)
Trace McSorley (1)
David Blough (1)
Nick Foles (2)
Skylar Thompson (1)
Gardner Minshew (2)
Desmond Ridder (3)
Trey Lance (2)
Zach Wilson (9)
Mike White (4)
Joe Flacco (3)
Sam Darnold (5)
P.J. Walker (5)
Jarrett Stidham (1)
John Wolford (3)
Bryce Perkins (1)
Tyler Huntley (4)
Kyle Allen (2)
Jeff Driskel (2)
Joshua Dobbs (1)
This is my order that I put together quickly. But generally, I think it’s pretty close to the order I’d finish with.
10
Posted on 2/14/23 at 1:52 pm to Suntiger
Somewhere in 31-40 sounds right.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:05 pm to Suntiger
quote:
Top 10
Patrick Mahomes (16)
Joe Burrow (15)
Aaron Rodgers (16)
Josh Allen (15)
Jalen Hurts (14)
Justin Herbert (16)
Lamar Jackson (12)
Deshaun Watson (5)
Matthew Stafford (9)
Kirk Cousins (16)
11-15
Russell Wilson (14)
Jimmy Garoppolo (10)
Trevor Lawrence (16)
Derek Carr (15)
Dak Prescott (11)
I'd take him over everyone in bold and would consider taking him over Dak as well if Dak got hurt again.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:11 pm to blackandgolddude
Stafford is done ... I would take him over him as well.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:11 pm to Suntiger
Can't believe we have to be left hanging on the decisions of this douchebag..
This post was edited on 2/14/23 at 2:12 pm
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:13 pm to blackandgolddude
I like your list except I'd take him over Dak.
I would also take him over Rodgers simply because of what it would cost to get Rodgers, and how long does he realistically have at this level?
Stafford would be a push and would go for whoever costs less between the 2.
I would also take him over Rodgers simply because of what it would cost to get Rodgers, and how long does he realistically have at this level?
Stafford would be a push and would go for whoever costs less between the 2.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:23 pm to Suntiger
Absolutely better than Carr:
Patrick Mahomes (16)
Joe Burrow (15)
Aaron Rodgers (16)
Josh Allen (15)
Jalen Hurts (14)
Justin Herbert (16)
Could be better but more equal to Carr:
Lamar Jackson (12)
Deshaun Watson (5)
Kirk Cousins (16)
Russell Wilson (14)
Jimmy Garoppolo (10)
Trevor Lawrence (16)
Tua Tagovailoa (13)
Patrick Mahomes (16)
Joe Burrow (15)
Aaron Rodgers (16)
Josh Allen (15)
Jalen Hurts (14)
Justin Herbert (16)
Could be better but more equal to Carr:
Lamar Jackson (12)
Deshaun Watson (5)
Kirk Cousins (16)
Russell Wilson (14)
Jimmy Garoppolo (10)
Trevor Lawrence (16)
Tua Tagovailoa (13)
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:36 pm to Suntiger
He is not better than Jared Goff, Geno Smith or Dak Prescott.
He is equal to Tua, Tannehill, and Jones.
So he is 17 for me.
Speaking of Goff, people really need to put some respect on him. Dude threw 29 TD last season without their 1st round pick Jameson Williams for pretty much the whole year and then they traded Hockenson to the Vikings pretty early in the year too. He doesn’t turn the ball over much either.
He is equal to Tua, Tannehill, and Jones.
So he is 17 for me.
Speaking of Goff, people really need to put some respect on him. Dude threw 29 TD last season without their 1st round pick Jameson Williams for pretty much the whole year and then they traded Hockenson to the Vikings pretty early in the year too. He doesn’t turn the ball over much either.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 2:46 pm to Suntiger
He’s a top 20 qb but not a top 19 qb
Posted on 2/14/23 at 3:07 pm to Suntiger
(no message)
This post was edited on 2/14/23 at 5:18 pm
Posted on 2/14/23 at 3:28 pm to blackandgolddude
Dak is 2-3 years younger and has had 1 semi bad year out of 7 and it came in the midst of a thumb injury in his throwing hand. Go Check his stats since his Jr year in college. He is an extremely low turnover QB. This past year was an aberration.
If the money is equal, which it isn’t obviously.
Dak is the far better QB than Carr. I’d probably also rather pay Dak $40 mil a year than Carr $25M. That’s how wide the gap is in my eyes.
If the money is equal, which it isn’t obviously.
Dak is the far better QB than Carr. I’d probably also rather pay Dak $40 mil a year than Carr $25M. That’s how wide the gap is in my eyes.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 3:37 pm to Suntiger
quote:
16-20
Posted on 2/14/23 at 4:20 pm to 3PieceSpicy
Dude. Dak is fine but nothing more.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 4:50 pm to Suntiger
oh...17.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 7:20 pm to Suntiger
You pretty much have to think he’s top 8 for the money to make sense.
It’s a bad idea to sign Carr. Realistically, he’s 15ish and he has Russell Wilson disaster potential.
It’s a bad idea to sign Carr. Realistically, he’s 15ish and he has Russell Wilson disaster potential.
Posted on 2/14/23 at 9:02 pm to moneyg
It’s scary if people think Carr is better than Watson, Lamar and Dak. Yikes
Posted on 2/15/23 at 1:27 am to VictoryHill
quote:
He is not better than Jared Goff, Geno Smith or Dak Prescott.
He is equal to Tua, Tannehill, and Jones.
So he is 17 for me.
Speaking of Goff, people really need to put some respect on him. Dude threw 29 TD last season without their 1st round pick Jameson Williams for pretty much the whole year and then they traded Hockenson to the Vikings pretty early in the year too. He doesn’t turn the ball over much either.
I love how this has received 11 downvotes. Goff was 6th in the league in TD passes, 6th in the league in yards, 7th in passer rating, 5th in 1st downs, 6th in yards per attempt, 7th in quarterback rating, and only threw 7 picks last year, including none in the final 9 games.
Further proof that most here wouldn't know really, really good QB play if it slapped them in the face. Probably the Carr fanboys.
Posted on 2/15/23 at 2:18 am to blackandgolddude
Lol. If Carr was even close to the qb Watson is, teams woukd have been blowing up the phone to gladly give up multiple first rounders and take in his 3 year 120 million dollar deal.
And we all saw how that turned out. Cousins is also better but prob not by much. Lawrence will be in the top 10 if he’s not already.
And we all saw how that turned out. Cousins is also better but prob not by much. Lawrence will be in the top 10 if he’s not already.
This post was edited on 2/15/23 at 2:20 am
Posted on 2/15/23 at 11:17 am to GynoSandberg
quote:
It’s scary if people think Carr is better than Watson, Lamar and Dak.
Watson was arse last year, I expected some initial struggles but not 6 games of pretty consistent bad play.
will be interesting to see if he returns to form as a top 10 QB
But yes, I’d rather have those 3 than Carr, and it’s not particularly close
Page 1 of 2
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News