These days there aren't many Police tracks that I don't skip over when they come up - Walking On The Moon, Bombs Away, and a couple from Outlandos maybe but other than that they haven't held up so well IMHO.
Regatta De Blanc is still a GOAT album, and if No Time This Time doesn´t get your blood up, then I don´t know what will. It is a very, very coherent and strong album,however some songs taken out of context, are weak alone, I agree.
I´d imagine you still like It´s Alright for You from Outlandos, as well as Next To You, Can´t Stand Losing You and So Lonely (possibly a perfect song). Outlandos had sheer brilliance, and one or two faux pauxs.
Starting with the third album, many a song have waned with the passing of time, but there are some strong ones interspersed there. I think their massive acceptance ran many a song into the ground, especially from Zenyatta Mondatta and Ghost in the Machine (which had alot of filler).