re: X Factor (Fox) Season Long Discussion Thread

I never thought I'd like Britney Spears more than Demi but I do. Demi tries too hard and totally just messed her team up. Just stupid decisions she has made.

I'm going to read your analysis and check out the show tomorrow. Had dinner plans and am not home yet. So I'll watch it when I can.

Britney is better than I thought, but not great. She's more poised than I expected and she doesn't go on and on.

I'm in the minority, but I like Tate. I think he gets a career from this.

Diamond stArted a bit weak, but did a fine job as she went on. She just get off this show and move on to Disney. She's made for Disney. Judges agreed with me on the slow start. Good job judges.

Khloe needs to be put out of my misery. She's intolerable, seriously.

Beatrice is so cute, but I agree with the judges that it wasn't the best song for her. There was only one stirring moment. Brit didn't do well by her after her being in the bottom. She needed some wow moments.

Lyric was okay, but not my kind of music so I didn't enjoy it at all.

Another poor song choice for Arin. Too slow and boring. No big moments. He may not make it this week.

I thought Paige held back and all that crap going on with her doesn't help her. She can do better than she did, but it was a good performance.

Fifth Harmony- I liked the song, the performance, the voice tones and the harmony. Enjoyed it. Not quite a wow, but they should hang around. I want to see them again.

Carly Rose is the one to beat. I said in the X Factor thread that I'm tired of that song, but I sure enjoyed that performance. She's incredible.

Great song for Vino and one I happen to like a lot. I got a back ache watching him bend over. I don't think he brought the song home like he could, though. He's got a great voice. LA needs to show it off more. Vino needs to not talk too much either.

Sheesh. Khloe can't stand up. She's a clutz in shoes and in speech.


Contrary to popular opinion, I was bored during Emblem 3's performance. No particular reason. Found myself thinking of other things. I like them but I wasn't sold this week.

I think Cece may have just saved Arin. Demi ruined her. What a train wreck. She looks like a whore and that may be part of the problem. She's not herself. I'm tired if her, though. She can go, but she can thank Demi for a good part of her early departure. She sang better as a brunette.

just watched last night's episode. really disappointed in lyric 145 that was god awful hope it doesn't send them home. the theme wasn't fitting for them and simon i guess pushed the limits of diva as far as he could but didn't work. emblem 3 did good but it seemed like emblem 1 the others were just there are not contributing. what simon has done with 5th harmony is amazing he is either the greatest mentor to ever live or they just got lucky with that grouping.

i was going to rank them but i dont see the point

1. carly rose

2-12. 11 other people that wish they had half of carly rose's talent

cece and arin go home tonight

what the frick is america doing

eta: paige better go home or i will be pissed

Someone tell me what is happening!! I won't be home for another 30 min

wow, she's insanely average.

Oh wow not janelle

Did they tell us how the votes fell?