In really surprised Nicholas is still getting America's votes...we all wondered if they would relate to him enough. But I'm glad he's still here.
quote:really? that was probably my favorite performance by melanie of the whole competition. nick of course killed it but i really did enjoy melanie's addition to the song also
While Melanie had some moments during "Criminal", I expected more from her. Nick, on the other hand, carried the song. She seemed like she was up there doing a job while he seemed like he was having angry sex with the song.
quote:why are you apologizing to me? nick deserved to go over amanda so did cassadee trevin and terry
Sorry, Hat, but when Nicholas and Amanda were standing there, I thought about it and in spite of what Saint Nick did last night, I wanted to hear more from him. Mainly, I wanted to see what he would do next. I think they're going to force him to bring it home next week if he wants to stay. I want to see that. Amanda, not so much.
I'm just glad Melanie is gone
I also caught the weird "Come here little girl" and hug that Carson pulled. Dude thinks he is best friends with everyone on the show
quote:i didn't mean it the way it sounded. amanda easily belongs in the final 4 but i am not mad at any of those chosen above her. the only one i didnt think should move on was melanie so any of the others i would've been ok with. imo they all belong so they deserve to go
Don't agree with you though.
quote:i REALLY hope that carly rose gets handled correctly after the show. i think she has a chance to be the most successful of all past contestants on any show. the control she has over her voice for 13 is magical.
I'm curious about how the X Factor folks will turn out.