Started By
Message

The Power Play in hockey is the best way to handle penalties of the 4 major sports leagues

Posted on 1/31/23 at 4:18 am
Posted by WaterLink
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2015
17335 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 4:18 am
In football you're awarded yards and also downs. These yards can put a team in and out of scoring range because there's a finite number of yards on the field. Even worse they can give a team an automatic 1st down. Nothing more demoralizing than when it's 3rd and 10 and there's defensive holding and boom 5 yards and an auto first down when the QB may have not been looking that way anyway.

Basketball you get free throws. That's free points on the board for a basket that may or may not have been made. Scoring is so prevalent in the league that no one questions it and is usually (I say usually) balances out but sometimes it doesn't and you have one team getting like +20 points at the stripe compared to the opponent and even have players with the intention and strategy of fishing for fouls. Not a fun product to watch imo.

There really isn't a "penalty" in baseball akin to the other sports aside from ejections and stuff when players or managers feel like getting ejected. But as far as ref influence goes baseball is kind of inexcusable but we want to maintain the human element of inconsistent strike zones for reasons. So striking out looking on something outside the zone is ok because he should have swung at something outside the zone on a 1-2 count, he shouldn't have let it get to 1-2 according to the ump's subjective strike zone. OK

At least with hockey even though it's 5 on 4 (usually, sometimes it's 5 on 3 or 4 on 4 staggered) the team with the disadvantage can ice the puck legally without stoppage to burn time so they get a bit of a perk, and the team with the advantage still has to convert and not commit a penalty themselves during their time. They have to earn that shite it's not just awarded to them and most of the time they don't, the highest PP% in league history is 32% or just under 1/3 of the time. That's the best ever.
Posted by bee Rye
New orleans
Member since Jan 2006
33963 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 6:28 am to
Hockey has the best overtime as well
Posted by WITNESS23
Member since Feb 2010
13723 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 7:51 am to
They should definitely do it for goal to go situations. Ridiculous that if it's close the defense can keep trying to time the snap and jump off sides with almost no penalty but if the offense gets a holding they back up 10 yards.

They should remove defensive players in those situations.
Posted by Oilfieldbiology
Member since Nov 2016
37583 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 8:11 am to
I think it would be fun if every penalty was that player sat out the next play. No yardage or down adjustment. Just line up the next play with 10 guys
Posted by EZE Tiger Fan
Member since Jul 2004
50411 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 8:14 am to
Hockey really is the best sport out there in terms of athletic ability of the players, how a champion is determined (long playoff series), and officiating control. It will never gain more traction in the US, unfortunately. Couple that with the sport consisting of a lot of white, foreign players that refuse to abide by woke US narratives, and it will continued to be "ignored" purposely by the media. The only time hockey gets big play here is if team USA does something decent every four years.
Posted by Rig
BHM
Member since Aug 2011
41856 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 8:30 am to
quote:

Couple that with the sport consisting of a lot of white, foreign players that refuse to abide by woke US narratives
Which is ironic because I would consider the NHL to be the farthest left of any sports organization.

The NHL sponsored a transgender hockey game lately and it was a disaster
Posted by BCLA
Bossier City
Member since Mar 2005
8111 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 8:43 am to
Don't forget about the penalty shot too.
Posted by Furbs311
South Carolina
Member since Oct 2005
516 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 8:52 am to
What’s the overtime rules these days?

I use to go to lots of Hurricanes games growing up before there were shootouts and saw a lot of tie games. Went to a minor league game a few months ago - after regulation they went to a 7:00 3-3 sudden death period, then a shootout. It was a lot of fun to watch
Posted by mrbroker
Sylacauga Alabama
Member since Jul 2011
16575 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 8:57 am to
Soccer has the same thing with the PK
Posted by TomRollTideRitter
Member since Aug 2016
12620 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 9:13 am to
quote:

Which is ironic because I would consider the NHL to be the farthest left of any sports organization.


The NHL maybe does more LGBT stuff because they can’t play the race angle as much.

I think they’re all pretty awful about it. I’m not sure how you distinguish one over the other.
Posted by Oilfieldbiology
Member since Nov 2016
37583 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 9:25 am to
quote:

Don't forget about the penalty shot too.


A penalty shoot out in over time hockey feels like it’s much more akin to actual game play than penalty shots in soccer. In hokey there are breakaways that routinely result in shooter v goalie 1 on 1 as opposed to soccer penalty kicks
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
76551 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 9:32 am to
quote:

Hockey really is the best sport out there in terms of athletic ability of the players, how a champion is determined (long playoff series), and officiating control. It will never gain more traction in the US, unfortunately. Couple that with the sport consisting of a lot of white, foreign players that refuse to abide by woke US narratives, and it will continued to be "ignored" purposely by the media. The only time hockey gets big play here is if team USA does something decent every four years.


This may be true in the South, but it's a big deal for most cities up north and Canada obviously.
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
76551 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 9:34 am to
quote:

I use to go to lots of Hurricanes games growing up before there were shootouts and saw a lot of tie games. Went to a minor league game a few months ago - after regulation they went to a 7:00 3-3 sudden death period, then a shootout. It was a lot of fun to watch


quote:

What’s the overtime rules these days?


Regular Season:

5 mins 3v3, then a 3 man shootout

Playoffs:

5v5, 20 minute extended periods, golden goal
Posted by Weekend Warrior79
Member since Aug 2014
16469 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 11:49 am to
quote:

I think it would be fun if every penalty was that player sat out the next play. No yardage or down adjustment. Just line up the next play with 10 guys

While something needs to be done, this isn't it. 3rd and long (6+), just have the CB commit a PI when the ball is in the air to keep the 1st down from happening. Now it's 4th & 6+ and the defense just has to field the ball with 10 players.
Posted by Topwater Trout
Red Stick
Member since Oct 2010
67593 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 12:14 pm to
quote:

the team with the disadvantage can ice the puck legally without stoppage to burn time so they get a bit of a perk,


why should they get a perk though...they are being penalized.

I think some of the football penalties are stupid. Since they are based on yardage a team shouldn't be given an automatic first down for a 5 yard holding call when it's 3rd a 15...replay the down and make it 3rd and 10.
Posted by dnm3305
Member since Feb 2009
13615 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 1:11 pm to
So let’s apply this to football and make the defense have to sit a defensive back for 2:00. You don’t think that would be an EXTREMELY big advantage to the offense and vastly increase the rate of scoring?
Posted by McVick
Member since Jan 2011
4471 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 2:08 pm to
To throw this out there, the team playing with the penalty in hockey still has a rare opportunity to score. Short-hand goals are great unless it happens to your team.
Posted by Cosmo
glassman's guest house
Member since Oct 2003
120423 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 2:10 pm to
quote:

Hockey has the best overtime as well


Nah. Baseball you just keep playing the same game til somebody wins which is the best way to do it
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
76551 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 2:14 pm to
quote:

Nah. Baseball you just keep playing the same game til somebody wins which is the best way to do it


That's how the NHL playoffs are.

Doesn't MLB start with a runner on 2nd now or did they get rid of that?
Posted by Cosmo
glassman's guest house
Member since Oct 2003
120423 posts
Posted on 1/31/23 at 2:20 pm to
quote:

That's how the NHL playoffs are.


They got rid of shootouts in playoffs?
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram