I hate the idea of Freshmen QB's coming in and not RSing.
To me, that means the starter and/or back up isn't good enough to hold off a freshman QB. Freshmen QB's are inexperienced and do not grasp the entire offense....hence, offenses are hand cuffed.
Let them put on some weight, learn the playbook and gain some experience on the practice field.
Redshirt them both. If history tells us anything, whichever one wins the job and is clearly the #1 guy, the #2 guy will eventually transfer for playing time.
This post was edited on 2/18 at 1:50 pm