The last of us or 3 other games?

Tough call, TLoU is the best of those 3 games and probably worth it over the other 3.

But 3>1 at the same time.

I'd still go TLoU.

TLoU

Always go with greatness

Red dead isn't far behind but I'd still go with just tLou

BTW I'm getting PS+ does it still have Battlefield for free?

For how much longer is it up?

Get the 3. Shadow of the colossus is awesome and so is red dead. Those are two great games over 1 great game. Then you get battlefield

red dead is a great title, it is unbelievable. With that said, you just cannot beat TLOU. It's 18 hours but you'll want to play it again. It's just incredible. If you have to choose between the 2, do not hesitate.

Red dead was great, but the story was nowhere near as compelling and while I love the characters, Ellie might be the best video game character ever as far as feeling like a real person. She's more interesting and there is a lot going on with her being born in the zombo apocalypse.

I finished The Last of Us single player last night and would definitely recommend playing the game at some point regardless of what you do. If you enjoy survival/horror types of games with emphasis stealth, then you will enjoy The Last of Us. I have haven't played the multiplayer, so I can't comment on that. It also took me around 18 to 20 hours to finish the campaign and to me the game is worth a second playthrough. Personally, I've played the other 3 games you've mentioned and they are awesome, but I would go with the Last of Us.

Get the three other games.