- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Louisiana Craft Brewery Scoring - 2024
Posted on 3/4/24 at 2:21 pm
Posted on 3/4/24 at 2:21 pm
Seeing as craft brewing is in a bit of a downturn right now, how do you rate each brewery in Louisiana. Breweries will be assigned up to a total of 58 points based on the following parameters. This is a subjective ranking, so vote based on your opinions of that brewery and their beer. We’ll keep this thread open for scoring for a few weeks and then I’ll make efforts to compile the scores in a spreadsheet and post them later. (If there is a brewery missing that you think needs to be added or deleted, let me know.)
Breweries will be assigned a score based on:
Quality - 18 pts - this will be your measure of the overall quality of the beer. Flavor, Aroma, how well they nail the style they are brewing, etc... Do they make great beer or meh beer?
Brewery Atmosphere - 15 points - Assign up to 12 points based on the atmosphere of the brewery. Do they serve food? Amenities (trivia night, kid friendly, dog friendly, etc...) Does the brewery have an atmosphere that matters to you? Is it a dive and is that a good thing to you? Is the brewery stale/boring/uninviting?
Price - 8 points - Are you willing to pay the price for the beer? Is it appropriate or is it overpriced?
Style Variety – 6 points – Does the brewery brew multiple styles? Do they have varying styles available or are they more of a 1 trick pony. This isn’t the quality of the style, but rather the variety of styles they bring to the table.
Social Media - 6 points – Do they have a large social media presence? Do they advertise and post weekly about new beer releases, events, specials? And then the down side of social media, are they fairly neutral or are you berated by their politics? Or, if you like their politics, is that a plus?
Distribution/Packaging - 5 points - What is their distribution reach? Are you able to acquire these beers or is it mostly brewery only. Does the brewery keep 4 packs available, or is it crowler/growler only? Or, is it tap only, no packaging at all?
Quality (18 pts) –
Brewery Atmosphere (15 pts) –
Price (8 pts) –
Style Variety (6 pts) –
Social Media (6 pts) –
Distribution (5 pts) -
TOTAL (58 pts) -
Breweries:
North Louisiana
Great Raft:
Red River Brewing Company:
Seventh Tap:
Flying Heart Brewery:
Flying Tiger
Cane River Brewing
Natchez Brewing Company
Key City Brewing Company
Utility Brewing
Central Louisiana:
Huckleberry Brewing Co.:
Broken Wheel Brewery
Twenty 8 West
Southwest Louisiana:
Crying Eagle
Parish
Bayou Teche
Adopted Dog Brewing
Capital Area/Region:
Tin Roof
Cypress Coast
Agile Brewing
Rally Cap
Gilla Brewing Co.
Istrouma Brewing Company
Grain Creations
I12 Corridor/North Shore:
Abita
Le Chien
Gnarly Barley
Low Road
Chafunkta
Southeast/NOLA Region:
Brieux Carre
Parleaux
Miel
Ecology Beer Creative
NOLA
Courtyard Brewing
Faubourg
Oak St. Brewery
Brewery Saint X
Port Orleans
Mudbug
Zony Mash
Urban South
Second Line
Bywater Brew Pub
Skeeta Hawk Brewing
ETA: Edited to add packaging to the distribution scoring.
Breweries will be assigned a score based on:
Quality - 18 pts - this will be your measure of the overall quality of the beer. Flavor, Aroma, how well they nail the style they are brewing, etc... Do they make great beer or meh beer?
Brewery Atmosphere - 15 points - Assign up to 12 points based on the atmosphere of the brewery. Do they serve food? Amenities (trivia night, kid friendly, dog friendly, etc...) Does the brewery have an atmosphere that matters to you? Is it a dive and is that a good thing to you? Is the brewery stale/boring/uninviting?
Price - 8 points - Are you willing to pay the price for the beer? Is it appropriate or is it overpriced?
Style Variety – 6 points – Does the brewery brew multiple styles? Do they have varying styles available or are they more of a 1 trick pony. This isn’t the quality of the style, but rather the variety of styles they bring to the table.
Social Media - 6 points – Do they have a large social media presence? Do they advertise and post weekly about new beer releases, events, specials? And then the down side of social media, are they fairly neutral or are you berated by their politics? Or, if you like their politics, is that a plus?
Distribution/Packaging - 5 points - What is their distribution reach? Are you able to acquire these beers or is it mostly brewery only. Does the brewery keep 4 packs available, or is it crowler/growler only? Or, is it tap only, no packaging at all?
Quality (18 pts) –
Brewery Atmosphere (15 pts) –
Price (8 pts) –
Style Variety (6 pts) –
Social Media (6 pts) –
Distribution (5 pts) -
TOTAL (58 pts) -
Breweries:
North Louisiana
Great Raft:
Red River Brewing Company:
Seventh Tap:
Flying Heart Brewery:
Flying Tiger
Cane River Brewing
Natchez Brewing Company
Key City Brewing Company
Utility Brewing
Central Louisiana:
Huckleberry Brewing Co.:
Broken Wheel Brewery
Twenty 8 West
Southwest Louisiana:
Crying Eagle
Parish
Bayou Teche
Adopted Dog Brewing
Capital Area/Region:
Tin Roof
Cypress Coast
Agile Brewing
Rally Cap
Gilla Brewing Co.
Istrouma Brewing Company
Grain Creations
I12 Corridor/North Shore:
Abita
Le Chien
Gnarly Barley
Low Road
Chafunkta
Southeast/NOLA Region:
Brieux Carre
Parleaux
Miel
Ecology Beer Creative
NOLA
Courtyard Brewing
Faubourg
Oak St. Brewery
Brewery Saint X
Port Orleans
Mudbug
Zony Mash
Urban South
Second Line
Bywater Brew Pub
Skeeta Hawk Brewing
ETA: Edited to add packaging to the distribution scoring.
This post was edited on 3/5/24 at 3:13 pm
Posted on 3/4/24 at 3:08 pm to BugAC
I just wanna know how many are even bothering with distribution anymore. I've heard some nasty crap about the demands from distributors to get fair treatment. Can't imagine why.
Posted on 3/4/24 at 3:08 pm to BugAC
Parish
Quality - 17
Atmosphere - 10
Price - 6
Social media - 3
Distribution - 5
Bayou Teche:
Quality - 12
Atmosphere - 14
Price - 7
Style variety - 5
Social media - 5
Distribution - 5
Tin Roof
Quality - 8
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 8
Variety - 4
Social media - 5
Distribution - 4
Rally Cap:
Quality - 7
Atmosphere - 11
Price - 4
Variety - 2
Social media - 3
Distribution - 3
Gilla Brewing Co.
Quality - 17
Atmosphere - 5
Price - 5
variety - 3
Social media - 3
Distribution - 3
Abita
Quality - 9
Atmosphere - 13
Price - 8
Variety - 2
Social media - 6
Distribution - 5
Le Chien:
Quality - 12
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 2
Variety - 2
Social media - 3
Distribution - 2
Gnarly Barley:
Quality - 13
Atmosphere - 14
Price - 8
Variety - 4
Social media - 6
Distribution - 5
Brieux Carre
Quality - 7
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 2
Variety - 5
Social media - 4
Distribution - 1
NOLA
Quality - 8
Atmosphere - 10
Price - 7
Variety - 4
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 4
Courtyard Brewing
Quality - 11
Atmosphere - 11
Price - 3
Variety - 4
Social Media - 0
Distribution - 3
Faubourg
Quality - 0
Atmosphere - 13
Price - 5
Variety - 2
Social Media - 0
Distribution - 5
Urban South
Quality - 13
Atmosphere - 15
Price - 7
Variety - 6
Social media - 4
Distribution - 5
Quality - 17
Atmosphere - 10
Price - 6
Social media - 3
Distribution - 5
Bayou Teche:
Quality - 12
Atmosphere - 14
Price - 7
Style variety - 5
Social media - 5
Distribution - 5
Tin Roof
Quality - 8
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 8
Variety - 4
Social media - 5
Distribution - 4
Rally Cap:
Quality - 7
Atmosphere - 11
Price - 4
Variety - 2
Social media - 3
Distribution - 3
Gilla Brewing Co.
Quality - 17
Atmosphere - 5
Price - 5
variety - 3
Social media - 3
Distribution - 3
Abita
Quality - 9
Atmosphere - 13
Price - 8
Variety - 2
Social media - 6
Distribution - 5
Le Chien:
Quality - 12
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 2
Variety - 2
Social media - 3
Distribution - 2
Gnarly Barley:
Quality - 13
Atmosphere - 14
Price - 8
Variety - 4
Social media - 6
Distribution - 5
Brieux Carre
Quality - 7
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 2
Variety - 5
Social media - 4
Distribution - 1
NOLA
Quality - 8
Atmosphere - 10
Price - 7
Variety - 4
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 4
Courtyard Brewing
Quality - 11
Atmosphere - 11
Price - 3
Variety - 4
Social Media - 0
Distribution - 3
Faubourg
Quality - 0
Atmosphere - 13
Price - 5
Variety - 2
Social Media - 0
Distribution - 5
Urban South
Quality - 13
Atmosphere - 15
Price - 7
Variety - 6
Social media - 4
Distribution - 5
This post was edited on 3/4/24 at 3:21 pm
Posted on 3/4/24 at 3:15 pm to Boudreaux35
quote:
I just wanna know how many are even bothering with distribution anymore
For my scoring, i'm trying to keep it rather even. I don't mind making a trip to a brewery to pick up beer if it's really good.
I'm going to adjust the distribution score to include packaging as well. Do they serve cans out the taproom or is it crowler only, or neither? Kingbob, you may want to adjust.
Posted on 3/4/24 at 5:21 pm to kingbob
quote:
Parish
Quality - 17
Atmosphere - 10
Have they done some different things the past 8 years or so?
That’s the last time I’ve been, but back then, I’d have given about 2 points on atmosphere.
Obviously top-tier quality, but I basically used to drink one pint then just buy beer to take home and drink.
This post was edited on 3/4/24 at 5:22 pm
Posted on 3/4/24 at 5:57 pm to kingbob
quote:
Parish Quality - 17 Atmosphere - 10 Price - 6 Social media - 3 Distribution - 5
The distribution for Parish could be better, especially for people north of the lake. It seems like Covington and Mandeville get anything they have to offer, 30 miles north, not so much.
Posted on 3/4/24 at 7:53 pm to ragincajun03
quote:
Have they done some different things the past 8 years or so?
No sir. Same as years past in regards to tap room experience
Posted on 3/4/24 at 8:07 pm to heypaul
quote:
Why not do a scale of 1-10?
I figured beer quality and atmosphere should be weighed more heavily than other categories.
If you mean overall, because 1-10 is kind of boring and doesn’t tell me much about breweries I haven’t been to.
This post was edited on 3/4/24 at 8:24 pm
Posted on 3/4/24 at 9:33 pm to BugAC
quote:
Central Louisiana:
Huckleberry Brewing Co.:
Broken Wheel Brewery
Cenla = only 2 = too many Baptist
Huckleberry brews up some good stuff, as well as Twenty 8 West which isn't on the list.
Posted on 3/5/24 at 9:24 am to kingbob
quote:
Abita
quote:
Variety - 2
Abita Brew Pub or Abita Brewery?
The brewery taproom has about 20 beers not sold in stores and unique.
Abita Brew Pub mainly has the beers sold in stores.
Posted on 3/5/24 at 9:33 am to BeepBopBoop
Variety isn’t about how many different styles of beers they offer but how many beers they offer that are actually worth trying. Abita makes one really solid wheat beer and flavors it. The brew pup experiments with different variations, but rarely does abita put out anything that isn’t a fruit flavored wheat beer that’s worth a crap. I did really like their vanilla triple dog they released last year, though.
Gilla gets knocked for this too. While they make the best milkshake ipas and sours in the state, they pretty much ONLY make those styles and aren’t really great at anything else. Rally Cap pretty much only makes IPA’s too.
Gilla gets knocked for this too. While they make the best milkshake ipas and sours in the state, they pretty much ONLY make those styles and aren’t really great at anything else. Rally Cap pretty much only makes IPA’s too.
Posted on 3/5/24 at 10:02 am to kingbob
The brew pub and the brewery are 2 different things.
The Abita Brew Pub is a restaurant that has the beers sold in stores made by Abita on tap.
The Abita Brewery Taproom has 20 or 25 beers and 10 at least that aren’t sold in stores and may never be sold in stores. Neapolitan Stout for instance. Not just fruit flavored wheat beers.
I enjoy both places but the Brewery Taproom has, IMO, a really good variety of beers, most which are way better than the beers Abita bottles and sells. The taproom had a chocolate hefe couple years ago that was incredible but never had it since and was never bottled.
I thought the ranking was ranking the actual breweries, not just the variety they sell in stores.
The Abita Brew Pub is a restaurant that has the beers sold in stores made by Abita on tap.
The Abita Brewery Taproom has 20 or 25 beers and 10 at least that aren’t sold in stores and may never be sold in stores. Neapolitan Stout for instance. Not just fruit flavored wheat beers.
I enjoy both places but the Brewery Taproom has, IMO, a really good variety of beers, most which are way better than the beers Abita bottles and sells. The taproom had a chocolate hefe couple years ago that was incredible but never had it since and was never bottled.
I thought the ranking was ranking the actual breweries, not just the variety they sell in stores.
This post was edited on 3/5/24 at 10:08 am
Posted on 3/5/24 at 10:14 am to BugAC
quote:
Capital Area/Region:
Tin Roof
Cypress Coast
Agile Brewing
Rally Cap
Gilla Brewing Co.
Istrouma Brewing Company
This is where I stopped reading. Then I read:
quote:
Brewery Atmosphere (15 pts) –
Price (8 pts) –
Style Variety (6 pts) –
Social Media (6 pts) –
Distribution (5 pts)
Posted on 3/5/24 at 12:28 pm to BugAC
Parleaux
Quality - 16
Atmosphere - 11
Price - 7
Variety - 6
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 1
Ecology
Quality - 15
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 6
Variety - 4
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 1
Skeeta Hawk
Quality - 12
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 7
Variety - 4
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 1
Quality - 16
Atmosphere - 11
Price - 7
Variety - 6
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 1
Ecology
Quality - 15
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 6
Variety - 4
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 1
Skeeta Hawk
Quality - 12
Atmosphere - 12
Price - 7
Variety - 4
Social Media - 4
Distribution - 1
Posted on 3/5/24 at 3:07 pm to vistajay
Breiux Carre
Quality 17
Atmosphere 12
Price 6
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 47
Parleaux
Quality 18
Atmosphere 13
Price 6
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 49
Ecology
Quality 16
Atmosphere 13
Price 6
Variety 4
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 45
Saint X
Quality 15
Atmosphere 11
Price 6
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 3
Total 45
Agile
Quality 15
Atmosphere 9
Price 6
Variety 6
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 44
Cypress Coast
Quality 14
Atmosphere 11
Price 6
Variety 4
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 42
Parish
Quality 17
Atmosphere 9
Price 4
Variety 4
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 44
Rally Cap
Quality 11
Atmosphere 10
Price 4
Variety 2
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 36
Bayou Teche
Quality 8
Atmosphere 15
Price 7
Variety 3
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 42
Tin Roof
Quality 10
Atmosphere 11
Price 8
Variety 4
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 42
Gnarly Barley
Quality 14
Atmosphere 14
Price 8
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 51
NOLA
Quality 8
Atmosphere 10
Price 6
Variety 3
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 35
Urban South
Quality 10
Atmosphere 12
Price 7
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 44
Istrouma
Quality 2
Atmosphere 12
Price 3
Variety 3
Social Media 2
Distribution/Packaging 0
Total 22
Le Chien
Quality 8
Atmosphere 12
Price 3
Variety 4
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 1
Total 32
Quality 17
Atmosphere 12
Price 6
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 47
Parleaux
Quality 18
Atmosphere 13
Price 6
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 49
Ecology
Quality 16
Atmosphere 13
Price 6
Variety 4
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 45
Saint X
Quality 15
Atmosphere 11
Price 6
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 3
Total 45
Agile
Quality 15
Atmosphere 9
Price 6
Variety 6
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 44
Cypress Coast
Quality 14
Atmosphere 11
Price 6
Variety 4
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 2
Total 42
Parish
Quality 17
Atmosphere 9
Price 4
Variety 4
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 44
Rally Cap
Quality 11
Atmosphere 10
Price 4
Variety 2
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 36
Bayou Teche
Quality 8
Atmosphere 15
Price 7
Variety 3
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 42
Tin Roof
Quality 10
Atmosphere 11
Price 8
Variety 4
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 42
Gnarly Barley
Quality 14
Atmosphere 14
Price 8
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 51
NOLA
Quality 8
Atmosphere 10
Price 6
Variety 3
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 4
Total 35
Urban South
Quality 10
Atmosphere 12
Price 7
Variety 5
Social Media 5
Distribution/Packaging 5
Total 44
Istrouma
Quality 2
Atmosphere 12
Price 3
Variety 3
Social Media 2
Distribution/Packaging 0
Total 22
Le Chien
Quality 8
Atmosphere 12
Price 3
Variety 4
Social Media 4
Distribution/Packaging 1
Total 32
This post was edited on 3/5/24 at 3:16 pm
Posted on 3/5/24 at 3:12 pm to BugAC
You left out Grain Creations in Gonzales
Posted on 3/5/24 at 3:13 pm to nicholastiger
quote:
You left out Grain Creations in Gonzales
Added, thanks!
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News