re: Picking 5th in a 12 man baseball league. Best strategy? (Mock on pg 2.)

Ok so I did a second mock. This time with Machado at 5. I went best available after that. I would definitely have to work on my pitching staff as the year goes along but I like my bats and versatility.

Which team would you rather have?

Team 1-- (first mock)
1. Correa (Hou - SS)
2. José Abreu (CWS - 1B)
3. Nelson Cruz (Sea - OF)
4. David Price (Bos - SP)
5. Dallas Keuchel (Hou - SP)
6. Johnny Cueto (SF - SP)
7. Brian Dozier (Min - 2B)
8. Anthony Rendón (Was - 2B,3B)
9. Brett Gardner (NYY - OF)
10. Brian McCann (NYY - C,1B)
11. Huston Street (LAA - RP)
12. Jeff Samardzija (SF - SP)
13. Daniel Murphy (Was - 1B,2B,3B)
14. David Peralta (Ari - OF)
15. Dexter Fowler (ChC - OF)
16. Sean Doolittle (Oak - RP)
17. Luis Severino (NYY - SP)
18. Mike Leake (StL - SP)
19. Brock Holt (Bos - 1B,2B,3B,SS,OF)
20. Kevin Kiermaier (TB - OF)
21. Edinson Vólquez (KC - SP)
22. Kyle Gibson (Min - SP)
23. Will Smith (Mil - RP)

Team 2-- (second mock)
1. Manny Machado (Bal - 3B,SS)
2. Buster Posey (SF - C,1B)
3. Nelson Cruz (Sea - OF)
4. Félix Hernández (Sea - SP)
5. Robinson Canó (Sea - 2B)
6. Todd Frazier (CWS - 3B)
7. Jacoby Ellsbury (NYY - OF)
8. Danny Salazar (Cle - SP)
9. Jonathan Lucroy (Mil - C,1B)
10. Brett Gardner (NYY - OF)
11. Huston Street (LAA - RP)
12. Jeff Samardzija (SF - SP)
13. Curtis Granderson (NYM - OF)
14. Matt Holliday (StL - OF)
15. Justin Verlander (Det - SP)
16. Yordano Ventura (KC - SP)
17. Drew Smyly (TB - SP)
18. J.J. Hoover (Cin - RP)
19. Neil Walker (NYM - 2B)
20. Carlos Santana (Cle - 1B)
21. Michael Conforto (NYM - OF)
22. Alcides Escobar (KC - SS)
23. Ian Kennedy (KC - SP)

Easily the second team.