Started By
Message

re: State / Local taxes on chopping block in GOP tax plan.

Posted on 10/22/17 at 12:25 pm to
Posted by Wednesday
Member since Aug 2017
15467 posts
Posted on 10/22/17 at 12:25 pm to
I've always thought this should be eliminated as a deduction, even though I live in Louisiana which has a state income tax.

I am a firm believer in anything that "exposes" taxes and their effects to people. For example, there is a total freak out everytime sales taxes get raised. It's because people know they will pay more - and there is NO avoiding it. If state income tax were not deductible - people would scream bloody murder every time it was raised.

Eliminating the deduction is the ONLY way people get interested in local governments, and how they spend our money. Plus it is the only way for me to stop funding (essentially by a tax credit issued to taxpayers in other states) insane public policies in states like California that has basically done nothing I agree with in the last 50 years. If those morons want to keep rolling along like they already are - fine - but I'm tired of paying for their dysfunction.

I'd be fine if we abolished the IRS entirely and income taxes entirely and just paid for all government services with sales taxes. Nobody is exempt from sales taxes. And government works better when people are paying attention to it.

One question I do not know the answer to . . .and maybe somebody does . . . Is it unconstitutional for there to be a requirement on any ballot initiative affecting property taxes - that the voter is a property owner. I've never understood how people could vote on an increase to property tax, when they don't own property. That seems like taxation without representation to me.

TLDR: in short, I would be totally fine with this change, especially if it were accompanied by a change in the due date of tax returns to the Tuesday before election day. Along with a law that said nobody gets to receive any tax credit resulting in a greater number than net zero in paid taxes. It's dysfunctional crap for anyone to ever get more in a tax "refund" than they paid in.
Posted by HubbaBubba
F_uck Joe Biden, TX
Member since Oct 2010
45858 posts
Posted on 10/22/17 at 12:47 pm to
quote:

I've never understood how people could vote on an increase to property tax, when they don't own property. That seems like taxation without representation to me.
The argument is that renters essentially raise their rents by voting for property taxes.

While Louisiana has historically had very low property taxes, the income tax sucks. Take a couple in Louisiana earning $400k a year and a $500k house. Take out a personal exemption and federal taxes and they owe, what? 6% on the balance and about $2k on property tax? Sound about right?

In Texas, same scenario: 0% income tax and about $12k in property tax, half what they'd pay in Louisiana. Those dollars go into the economy and help keep it stimulated, which enables the state to keep the overall tax burden relatively low.

Of course, additional explaining is necessary to describe how Texas does more with less: Texas manages the graft and corruption a little better than Louisiana which doesn't manage it at all. Too many fingers in the pie.
Posted by RTRinTampa
Central FL
Member since Jan 2013
5532 posts
Posted on 10/22/17 at 3:58 pm to
quote:

TLDR: in short, I would be totally fine with this change, especially if it were accompanied by a change in the due date of tax returns to the Tuesday before election day. Along with a law that said nobody gets to receive any tax credit resulting in a greater number than net zero in paid taxes. It's dysfunctional crap for anyone to ever get more in a tax "refund" than they paid in.


Why do you hate 53% of taxpayers? Seriously, I agree. $0 is where it ends. I know people because of EIC, Child Credit, etc... that pay in $3500 and get a check for $6500. That check should be capped at $3500.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram