Started By
Message

re: Live: President Trump Speaks at 75th Anniversary of the Battle at Coral Sea

Posted on 5/4/17 at 11:51 pm to
Posted by Mr.Perfect
Louisiana
Member since Mar 2013
17438 posts
Posted on 5/4/17 at 11:51 pm to
Alternative history really is fascinating.

What is JEB Stuart had been with Lee at the beginning of Gettysburg?
Posted by antibarner
Member since Oct 2009
23757 posts
Posted on 5/5/17 at 2:47 am to
Lee would have known what he was up against Day One..would he have done the same thing? No way to know, but perhaps not. He was of the opinion that it was the wrong battle but it had already been joined.
Posted by WhiskeyPapa
Member since Aug 2016
9277 posts
Posted on 5/5/17 at 6:33 am to
quote:

What is JEB Stuart had been with Lee at the beginning of Gettysburg?


Lee's hubris would have mooted his presence. Having learned nothing from Malvern Hill the year before Lee would gone "hey diddle diddle right up the middle" at G-Burg as he did in this reality and wrecked his army for offensive operations. Lee is vastly overrated. He did no better outside Virginia than many Federal generals did within it.

"In the course of four hours (at Malvern Hill) , a series of blunders in planning and communication had caused Lee's forces to launch three failed frontal infantry assaults across hundreds of yards of open ground, unsupported by Confederate artillery, charging toward firmly entrenched Union infantry and artillery defenses. These errors provided Union forces with an opportunity to inflict heavy casualties. In the aftermath of the battle, however, the Confederate press heralded Lee as the savior of Richmond."

LINK

first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram