re: The case against Derek Barnett

It's going to take time and I have a party for 2:00, but I'll edit this as the day goes. I started with the 3 teams I was unsure off (so these aren't even in the 18; and if the guy is nfl bound I'll take them out after).

Garrett game log

2014
Lamar roster
Guy he faced

Rice roster

Louisiana-Lafayette roster(OL pretty far down)
Guy he faced(might be an UDFA; outside of top 40 ranking)

2015
Arizona State depth chart
Guy he faced(might be an UDFA; outside of top 40 ranking)

Nevada depth chart


Louisville depth chart
Guy he faced(might be an UDFA; outside of top 50 ranking)

2016


And again this isn't to knock Garrett. It's to show that Barnett can hang with the big boys and did so more often than Garrett.

Edit:
So I'll give on that fact that MAYBE a few of these guy could be UDFAs next year or the year after, but being ranked outside of the top 40 at a position puts those prospects low (even lower to actually make a team), and outside the top 50 is a real long shot.

The UDFAs I counted for Barnett in the 19 (not the 27) actually made rosters and are still playing (1 even started a few games).