re: Greg Cosell "Rodgers Doesn't Execute the Offense and Misses Routine Throws"

quote:

---

Name one other rule where committing a foul is benificary.

---

Let's go to your next point

quote:

---

"Holding, on the offense, but since his quarterback got sacked, we gonna e force those holding. 1st and 20. Instead of 2nd and 20"

---

Pretty sure that holding on the offense, 10 yard penalty, is a lot better than an 8 yard sack, the QB getting hit, etc.

So thanks for doing that for me.

quote:

---

Bdk if you don't realize how fast the game moves and tough it already is on officials.

---

I've been on the field for plenty of games, and have officiated games at the HS level in the past. But thanks.

quote:

---

They already miss the PI part as you've pointed out, not you expect them to judge intent on top of that? Nope.

---

Jesus you're being dense if you think this would be a real burden on officials.

So the risk is that if they make a mistake, it has the same impact as it does now. Silly.

But I'm completely fine with having 15 yards across the board.

quote:

---

Defensive Holding is called when the ball is not yet in the air. That player being held is not the intended receiver. Makes all the difference.

---

Why does it make all the difference?