re: Is Dustin Pedrioa a hall of famer?

There was a discussion about this a few weeks ago. I believe Pedroia is two or three good seasons away from being a HOF caliber player. For me, Pedroia needs to reach at least 60 WAR to be considered a HOFer. Pretty much every HOF 2B who started their career after World War II accumulated 60 WAR. The one exception to the rule is Bill Mazeroski who was a very controversial pick and took forever to get in. But other than him, 60 WAR has usually been the benchmark or a HOF 2B. Pedroia's at 50 WAR right now for his career and is having a 5 WAR season this year. Considering his age, it's pretty much a lock he'll get to 60 WAR unless he has some terrible luck with injuries for the next few years. So yeah, I would say Pedroia is a HOFer as long as he can stay healthy and be productive for the next two or three seasons.