Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5 - Page 2 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
fightingtigers98
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Member since Oct 2011
9144 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:

The only really successful scrambler and passer I have seen for the same size of Manziel is Russell Wilson.

yeah wilson doesn't dance around the pocket, he runs when he has to. Manziel runs because he can.






Back to top
Melvin
New Orleans Saints Fan
Covington
Member since Apr 2011
11344 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:

Easy now, I'd love for tSaint's to draft him and let him sit and learn from Bree's for a year or two...
Brees will be playing at least 5 or 6 more years IMO






Back to top
jtran1988
LSU Fan
Tampa, Fl
Member since Oct 2008
2693 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


I'm sure Manziel will have the same elusiveness against NFL speed.






Back to top
Rommel
LSU Fan
North Africa
Member since Oct 2013
1362 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5




That'll change before the draft. He'll move up.






Back to top
Lifetigerfan
LSU Fan
South East Louisiana
Member since Mar 2013
288 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


Manzel is not an NFL qb no way NFL teams have him rated highly





Back to top
tiger4178
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2008
1211 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


It'd be cool as frick if Bree's can play another 5 or 6 years for tSaint's at his current productive rate, but it's simply not likely imo.

Manziel's future in tNFL is entirely dependent on him becoming a pass-first guy obviously, he's just too small to think otherwise, but he's also the exact same size as Bree's so why not learn from the master how to survive and thrive in tNFL.

And keep in mind, Johnny Football won't prolly demand that much leverage relatively speaking, he'll prolly be available in late 2nd or early 3rd so the risk/reward is a positive investment.






Back to top
JayDeerTay84
LSU Fan
Texas
Member since May 2013
1376 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


JFF still hasn't show the ability to NOT throw a jump ball.

The guy just tosses it in the air and 6'5 Evans makes a play.






Back to top
tiger4178
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2008
1211 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:

Manzel is not an NFL qb no way NFL teams have him rated highly


That's exactly the thought process that could make him available to tSaints's for cheap.






Back to top
Dr. Shultz
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Jun 2013
3000 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


Why would the saints want him?? he isn't a very good passer.





Back to top
tiger4178
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2008
1211 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:

Why would the saints want him?? he isn't a very good passer


Say's who?
Sure, he's known more for his running ability but ask Bama if his 500+ yards passing was a fluke.

He's maybe not NFL ready as a passer right this moment, but the skills are certainly there to be so.






Back to top
Rommel
LSU Fan
North Africa
Member since Oct 2013
1362 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


I agree, that's why Mett moves up.
I wouldn't want Manziel.
Mett? Of course. Tall, can see over the line, etc.
I'd like to see him more mobile.






Back to top
Folsom
LSU Fan
Folsom
Member since Mar 2006
297 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


Johnny Football is ahead of "Melkenberger" (ESPN Chick's Name for Mett)? How can this be? How is JF's upside stronger than Mett's?





Back to top
Dr. Shultz
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, La
Member since Jun 2013
3000 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:


Say's who?
Sure, he's known more for his running ability but ask Bama if his 500+ yards passing was a fluke.

He's maybe not NFL ready as a passer right this moment, but the skills are certainly there to be so.


Did you watch the game??

Most of his yards required no passing skills. He would just scramble around a lot and throw to a wide open receiver or throw a jump ball to Mike Evans.

He doesn't make NFL throws like some of the other QB's mentioned.



This post was edited on 10/10 at 8:56 pm


Back to top
Rommel
LSU Fan
North Africa
Member since Oct 2013
1362 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


I can't see him sitting in the pocket very long in the NFL either.






Back to top
Bengalroar
LSU Fan
Member since Aug 2013
887 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


Kiper sucks at this so that bodes for Mett in the draft. What has Kiper ever been right about?





Back to top
Rommel
LSU Fan
North Africa
Member since Oct 2013
1362 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


Kiper is usually right about things that are fairly obvious.
Like the sun setting, or the sun rise.






Back to top
Bear Is Dead
LSU Fan
Monroe
Member since Nov 2007
3507 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:

Kiper sucks at this so that bodes for Mett in the draft. What has Kiper ever been right about?

Enough to do this for a living.






Back to top
SouljaBreauxTellEm
LSU Fan
Mizz
Member since Aug 2009
23934 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5








Back to top
tiger4178
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2008
1211 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


quote:

Did you watch the game?? Most of his yards required no passing skills. He would just scramble around a lot and throw to a wide open receiver or throw a jump ball to Mike Evans. He doesn't make NFL throws like some of the other QB's mentioned


Of course I watched that game, and was very impressed with his competitiveness when he could have just given up hope.

Too many tangiables are taken into consideration nowadays in regards to potential for QB's. How many proto-type passers(ala JaMarcus?) have we seen fail at the next level?

It's the un-tangiables that make or break prospects, and I see Johnny Football as having plenty of those in regards to a possible future with tSaint's.






Back to top
Colonel Flagg
New Orleans Pelicans Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Apr 2010
9866 posts

re: Kiper's Top 10 QB Prospects: Mettenberger No. 5


I would think some GMs are going to reflect on Mett's season and realize he was highly productive in the SEC, was coached by Cameron, and he played in more of an NFL style offense.

Cameron being the biggest factor.



Also why would Brees drop off? That makes no sense as he has no injury issues and other QBs continue to be productive such as Manning.






Back to top


Back to top




//